George is busy homeschooling his stepdaughter, Madi. But they're interrupted when a social worker, Sean, checks on them, due to a tip from a concerned neighbor. George is nervous, especially as Madi innocently joins him at the door, but allows Sean inside to talk. As Sean asks Madi some questions, he learns that she's incredibly naive and that there's definitely more to the story than they're letting on... Marcus and Claire are a down-on-their-luck couple, having hit a string of bad luck recently which has left them without a place to live. Luckily, their college professor, Frank, has agreed to let them stay with him at his home. They assure him that they'll be back on their feet in no time. But as the days go by, the couple soon finds that Frank's open-door policy is a bit more intense than they initially expected.

Jessica is having a wonderful family game night with her husband Rod, her stepson David, and David's girlfriend Amy. Everything seems to be wholesome and going great until there's an unexpected knock at the door. Jessica excuses herself to cheerfully answer the door, then gets the shock of her life when she sees another woman smirking back at her. It's like looking in a mirror... and it's clear from the horror on Jessica's face that she doesn't like who is looking back at her. It seems like the past has caught up with Jessica and she's about to ruin every relationship she has with her family... and the relationship she has with herself.