- What’s up with the new federal permitting reform bill?

This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe

The proposed bipartisan federal permitting bill is 417 pages filled with extremely consequential provisions that have left the climate community some mix of excited, infuriated, and confused. In an attempt to bring some clarity, I asked Daniel Palken of Arnold Ventures, a veteran of Senate permitting fights, to walk through what’s in it. We cover the blockbuster transmission reforms, the rule making data centers pay more than their share of grid costs, the wins for geothermal, and the fossil carve-outs. Then we get into NEPA reforms that render the act toothless, limits on state water permits, and the permit-certainty sections that have lawyers worried about “forever permits.” And finally: whether it restrains Trump, why Democrats shouldn’t wait for a better deal, what the modeling says about emissions impacts, and Daniel’s odds of passage. This is a long one, folks. Buckle up.

Chapters:

00:00 – Intro: the bipartisan permitting bill

04:15 – Why permitting reform matters

12:23 – Agency staffing and capacity

16:59 – Past permitting attempts

20:26 – Transmission 1: planning and federal backstop

28:28 – Transmission 2: who pays and grid upgrades

38:17 – Data centers 1: paying more for grid access

43:20 – Distributed energy and geothermal

49:06 – Oil, gas, and mining provisions

57:06 – Data centers 2: will they go off-grid?

1:00:19 – NEPA 1: courts can’t halt projects

1:08:57 – NEPA 2: the main objections

1:17:10 – State water permits

1:23:35 – Endangered species

1:27:37 – Permit certainty 1: limits on revoking permits

1:36:43 – Permit certainty 2: lawsuits and damages

1:48:12 – Politics 1: Trump’s wind blockades

1:52:57 – Politics 2: why not wait for a better deal?

1:58:33 – Politics 3: elections, courts, and modeling

2:10:57 – Politics 4: next steps and odds of passage