职业社会学
Law School
Douban
Stevens, Robert 1987 - 2
In this first general history of legal education, Stevens traces the development of law schools, the legal profession, and legal thought, relating their evolution to intellectual, political, and social trends. He describes how the establishment gained power over education after 1920 and how, in the past two decades, both students and the practicing profession have questioned this authority. He also examines the implications of the "legal revolution" and new opportunities for women and minorities.
Read
Sept. 16, 2021
史料不错。浅显易懂。中译也很过硬。给我一个启发:塑造职业教育更多的是不是来自职业本身的特性(比方上庭、男性主导、以及垄断)。
职业社会学 美国
The Political Economy of Collective Skill Formation
Douban
Busemeyer, Marius R.; Trampusch, Christine; Busemeyer, Marius R. 2011 - 11
Education, skill formation, and training continue to be important areas of consideration for both public policy and research. This book examines the particular types of vocational training known as collective skill formation systems, whereby the training (often firm-based apprenticeships) is collectively organized by businesses and unions with state support and cooperation in execution, finance, and monitoring. With contributions from leading academics, this book is the first to provide a comprehensive analysis of the varying historical origins of, and recent developments in, vocational training systems, offering in-depth studies on coordinated market economies, namely Germany, Austria, Switzerland, the Netherlands, and Denmark. It also contains comparative chapters that analyse how these countries react to common challenges such as deindustrialization, labour market stratification, academic drift, gender inequalities, and Europeanization. Whereas previous research has focused on the differences between various kinds of skill regimes, this book focuses on explaining institutional variety within the group of collective skill formation systems. The development of skill formation systems is regarded as a dynamic political process, dependent on the outcome of various political struggles regarding such matters as institutional design and transformations during critical junctures in historical development.
The University and the Global Knowledge Society
Douban
David John Frank / John W. Meyer publishing house: The University of Princton Press 2020 - 5
The university is experiencing an unprecedented level of success today, as more universities in more countries educate more students in more fields. At the same time, the university has become central to a knowledge society based on the belief that everyone can, through higher education, access universal truths and apply them in the name of progress. This book traces the university’s rise over the past hundred years to become the cultural linchpin of contemporary society, revealing how the so-called ivory tower has become profoundly interlinked with almost every area of human endeavor. David John Frank and John Meyer describe how, as the university expanded, student and faculty bodies became larger, more diverse, and more empowered to turn knowledge into action. Their contributions to society underscored the public importance of scholarship, and as the cultural authority of universities grew they increased the scope of their research and teaching interests. As a result, the university has become the bedrock of today’s information-based society, an institution that is now implicated in the solution to every conceivable problem. But, as Frank and Meyer also show, the conditions that helped spur the university’s recent ascendance are not immutable: eruptions of nationalism, authoritarianism, and illiberalism undercut the university’s universalistic and rationalistic premises, and may threaten the centrality of the university itself.
Read
Aug. 12, 2021
World Society旧酒装新瓶。大学是universalism & rationalization的化身,结合经济的professionalization和知识化,成为了这个时代的上帝替代品(不知道有意还是无意,书里出现了好几次)。作为制度的大学有没有普遍性?在其象征意义下(知识生产),在其改变社会结构的方面,肯定有。这个制度有韧性和延续性,挺符合Varieties of Capitalism的论点。VoC的框架比这本书的要结构化和有说服力多了。
知识社会学 高等教育 职业社会学
How Institutions Evolve
Douban
Kathleen Thelen publishing house: 劍橋大學出版社 2004 - 9
Kathleen Thelen explains the historical origins of important cross-national differences in four countries (Germany, Britain, the United States and Japan), and also provides a theory of institutional change over time. The latter is considered a frontier issue in institutionalist analysis, of which there are several varieties emerging from economics, political science, and sociology. Thelen's study contributes to the literature on the political economy of the developed democracies that focuses on different institutional arrangements defining distinctive models of capitalism.
Read
Aug. 11, 2021
很多年前读过,这两天写稿重新翻看。无疑是一本杰作。Thelen 的论述非常清晰有力,在后续著作里延续了思维的一致性。但我现在的问题是,不同行业之间是如何互动的?——如果你相信学生会选择进入哪样的行业的话,不同行业的技能要求和准入门槛肯定影响行业的发展。我现在没有什么成型的思路,不过如果看Konrad Jarausch(律师、工程师、教师)的著作,你会发现同样的时代,同样的国家,职业培训制度非常不同。为什么?有什么影响?
经济史 职业社会学 德国 日本 职业教育
Beyond Monopoly
Douban
Terence C. Halliday publishing house: University Of Chicago Press 1987 - 9
How do professional associations build their resources and establish authroity? What are the conditions under which professional expertise can be mobilized for political action? If professional organizations are endowed with a wealth of resources, do they use them responsibly or only for economic monopoly? What is the potential scope of professional action today? In this pathbreaking study of the legal profession, Terence Halliday raises and addresses these questions combining extensive data from the rich archives o the Chicago Bar Association, one of the nation's largest and wealthiest bar organizations, with data from a national survey of bar legislative and judicial action. Beyond Monopoly demonstrates that the primary commitment of lawyers to economic monopoly has long been complemented by "civic professionalism" as the legal profession takes on more responsibility in the American democratic system when state capabilities diminish. Through his examination of three types of state crises in the 1950s and 1960s--the challenges to legitimacy in the legal system, the crisis of individual rights during McCarthyism and the civil rights eras, and the fiscal crises of various state governments--Halliday shows that large bar associations can have extensive influence on any institution that is regulated by law. He argues that lawyers have the capability of turning social and political issues into technical legal matters in what he calls an "idiom of legalism." Under technical guise, lawyers come to exercise moral authority. Halliday maintains that the American legal profession over the past century has gone from a formative stage, when controlling its market in the delivery of legal services was paramount, to an established phase in the past two decades, when it has committed extensive resources to the complex needs of the modern state. A de facto bargain has been struck: if the state leaves the profession's monopoly fairly intact, the profession can use its expert resources to help the state adapt to strain and crisis. It can do so not only in the legal system, where it has been championing "autonomous" law, but in other spheres as well--from the economy to the private sphere of individual rights. Halliday confirms that the legal profession deploys its expertise not merely to attain professional dominance, to control a market, or to purvey an ideology, but to increase the viability of democratic institutions. Beyond Monopoly introduces a pioneering approach to a historical and comparative sociology of the professions that will be of vital interest not only to sociologists, but to political scientists and lawyers as well.
The Sociology of the Professions
Douban
Keith M Macdonald publishing house: SAGE Publications Ltd 1995 - 11
This much-needed book provides a systematic introduction, both conceptual and applied, to the sociology of the professions. Keith Macdonald guides the reader through the chief sociological approaches to the professions, addressing their strengths and weaknesses. The discussion is richly illustrated by examples from and comparisons between the professions in Britain, the United States and Europe, relating their development to their cultural context. The social exclusivity that professions aim for is discussed in relation to social stratification, patriarchy and knowledge, and is thoroughly illustrated by reference to examples from medicine and other established professions, such as law and architecture. The themes of the book are drawn together in a final chapter by means of a case study of accountancy.
Read
May 11, 2021
选择性沿用Larson(韦伯的部分,马克思的部分扔掉了)套了个新框架出来(揉合了Abbott, Johnson和Halliday),不是特别令人满意。思考职业和国家关系这一点比美国作者要敏感,有启发。基本上数据都是二手文献,没有亮眼的地方。
社会学 职业社会学
The Future of the Army Profession
Douban
Matthews, Lloyd J. (EDT) publishing house: McGraw-Hill College 2005 - 4
Read
May 10, 2021
少有的社会学家理论被应用在当代职业研究中:这本书的由来是美国军校的教授们试图回答「美国军队究竟变成了现代化职业还是单纯的科层组织?」——答案是职业化项目完成之后军队就开始向后者变化了。很有意思的是,这是本书的第二版,恰逢阿富汗战争开打,作者们说军队的专家知识得益于战争(但在其它方面受到战争的负面影响,比方道德性)。还有,因为不是学术书籍,写作风格很新鲜,起码在那些军人作者的章节里,字里行间都有一股很利索的感觉(看看表9-1,社会学家谁会费心写这么多?)
美国 职业社会学 军事社会学
The Evolution of Management Education
Douban
Michael W. Sedlak / Harold F. Williamson publishing house: University of Illinois Press 1983
Read
May 9, 2021
老师写的书,关于西北大学商学院的历史。比较普通的地方史/高等教育史作品。提供了一个微观视角来看商学院怎么从普通商业培训(早期竞争对手是高中的职业部门)转到专业性的学科化培训模式。不过因为只写到80年代,所以没有涉及后期的发展。还是能看到很多大学发展里的共通主题:校园选址、和职业团体的关系、全国性「权威机构」对大学办学的影响等等。
历史 职业社会学
Moral Mazes
Douban Goodreads
Robert Jackall publishing house: Oxford University Press 2009 - 1 other title: Moral Mazes: The World of Corporate Managers
This classic study of ethics in business presents an eye-opening account of how corporate managers think the world works, and how big organizations shape moral consciousness. Robert Jackall takes the reader inside a topsy-turvy world where hard work does not necessarily lead to success, but sharp talk, self-promotion, powerful patrons, and sheer luck might. What sort of everyday rules-in-use do people play by when there are no fixed standards to explain why some succeed and others fail? In the words of one corporate manager, those rules boil down to this maxim: "What is right in the corporation is what the guy above you wants from you. That's what morality is in the corporation." This brilliant, disturbing, funny look at the ethos of the corporate world presents compelling real life stories of the men and women charged with running the businesses of America. This anniversary edition includes an afterword by the author linking the themes of Moral Mazes to the financial tsunami that engulfed the world economy in 2008.
Read
May 1, 2021
组织+职业研究的经典之作,通过三家不同类型的公司(纺织、化工、公关公司),折射出现代管理职业的方方面面,既是权力斗争的参与者,又是塑造自己社会关系的道德行动者。掌握领导喜好,行业黑话,掂量自己手中的资源,一应俱全。写作更是典范性的,用词言简意赅,句子精悍。要说缺陷的话是没有一个完整框架,六项实证洞察和大的「韦伯式道德观」(第一章)只有非常微弱的联系。出过一个中文版,我翻了下只有原书的一半厚度,不清楚为什么。
社会学 职业社会学 组织研究 领导力
Music on Demand
Douban
Faulkner, Robert R. 2003
Read
April 30, 2021
非常好的一本,属于被埋没的珍品。Faulkner研究的是70-80年代的好莱坞,作为「自由职业者」的电影作曲家们。数据材料上略有瑕疵(访谈为主),但勾勒自由职业的社会组织这一主题相当细致(Faulkner本人是一位出色的爵士小号演奏者),既有网络的视角,也有结构性流动和个体互动。印象最深的就是作曲家出名完全是随机事件。
社会学 职业社会学 艺术社会学
The Formation of Professions
Douban
Rolf Torstendahl / Michael Burrage publishing house: SAGE Publications 1990 - 7
Read
April 19, 2021
一套书的另一本,也是稍强一点点的那本。视角来自欧洲大陆,但是理论的部分经不起推敲,实证的部分,完全不如那些研究职业史的历史学家们Jarausch的德国来的丰富。
社会学 职业社会学
Professions in theory and history
Douban
Michael Burrage publishing house: Sage Publications 1990
The professions are currently the focus of vigorous debate within sociology and social history. This book and its companion volume (The Formation of Professions) bring together researchers from continental Europe and from the English-speaking world to highlight the contrasting perspectives of the two traditions and to emphasize what they can learn from each other. The present volume concentrates on the theory and historical development of professions. The authors identify critical problems of method and theory, such as the reliance on single-profession case studies, the separation of professions from their social and political contexts, the assumption of a uniform professional strategy, the neglect of inter-professional relations and above all the overwhelming Anglo-American bias embedded in the categories and concepts used. They then propose ways in which comparative and historical analysis might be better equipped to study the professions in a wide variety of social and political settings. The discussion encompasses the market and employment context, comparison of professions with other kinds of authority relations and other types of occupation, and exploration of historical discontinuities and variations in strategy.
Read
April 19, 2021
这套集子一共两册,除了历史章节之外(4,6,9),其它的「理论」部分古董。居然当年卖两本90多刀,疯了。
社会学 职业社会学
The Unfree Professions
Douban
Konrad Hugo Jarausch publishing house: Oxford University Press, USA 1990 - 9
How could educated professionals have supported the Nazi movement and collaborated with Hitler's inhuman policies? Jarausch examines this fascinating and largely unexplored subject, tracing the social, ideological, and political development of three representative German professions--law, teaching, and engineering--from the late Empire to the early Federal Republic. Based on a reformulated professionalization theory and on authoritative statistics, he describes professional prosperity and prestige in the Second Reich and analyzes the social crisis brought on by hyperinflation, stabilization, and Depression during the chaotic Weimar years. Threatened with the loss of livelihood and frightened by cultural disorientation, many experts embraced neo-conservative ideas and cooperated in Hitler's seizure of power. Welcoming the apparent restoration of their authority in the early Third Reich, professionals collaborated in the racial purges and warping of ethics, practices, and organizations under Nazi rule. During the Second World War, the radicalization of SS terror threatened the very survival of the professions so that most practitioners were only too happy to be rescued by Allied victory. Exploring the reluctant democratization of the post-war professions, Jarausch concludes with a reflection on the lessons of the German experience for the relationship between professionalism and liberty.
Read
Jan. 14, 2021
80年代的产物,把理想的「职业」对标英美的社会学文献,认为德国的「职业化」是十八世纪到十九世纪中产阶级形成最骄傲的成果(p226),就我感兴趣的教师问题,第一章最好。三个职业在政治光谱占据不同位置(律师liberal、教师national,工程师indifferent),最终都在纳粹德国时期被帝国吸收。作者认为德国职业化可以用新法团主义来概括,单就从叙事的角度来说说得过去,可是和同时代的生态论点一比就着实觉得缺乏动态。
职业社会学 社会学 史学 德国史 二战
割据的逻辑
Douban
刘思达 publishing house: 译林出版社 2017 - 10
本书将芝加哥社会学派的生态分析传统引入对中国法律职业的实证研究当中,在详细梳理了法律服务行业的源起和变迁之后,又搭建了相当宏大的理论体系,以解释行业内部和外部各种边界的产生。该体系还原了职业者与政府、社会和其他职业者之间的多元互动,在保存了复杂性的前提之下,极为精准地将这些互动抽象为“合界”、“分界”、“维界”与“共生交换”几种基础行为模式。此书堪称中国法律社会学的典范之作,值得所有法学研究者仔细阅读。增订本收入了《方庭的窗口:芝大留学往事》和《场域与生态》两篇文章。
Professional Dominance
Douban
Eliot Freidson publishing house: Aldine Transaction 2006
Read
Aug. 13, 2020
虽然被认为是「前范式」下的作品,但今天读起来依然写的非常帮。清晰、精准,还有文采(第二章多棒)。分工、控制市场准入、职业同侪间的社会化的见地现在一点都不过时。jurisdiction这个词应该是从这里来的吧?
职业社会学 医学社会学 社会学
學術人
Homo Academicvs Google Books Douban
★ 8.3 7 ratings
皮耶.布赫迪厄(Pierre Bourdieu) translator: 李沅洳 譯 / 林錚 審閱 publishing house: 時報文化 2019 - 12 other title: 學術人
一本「要燒掉的書」? 一本震驚法國學界的書! 社會學家布赫迪厄(Pierre Bourdieu)嚴謹而銳利的自我審視, 具體分析出身背景與人脈資源對於學術地位的影響。 《學術人》(Homo Academicvs)是已故法國知名社會學者--皮耶.布赫迪厄(Pierre Bourdieu)在一九八四年出版的暢銷著作,震動當時的法國學界,在他寫作這本書之前,並沒有人勇於自我挑戰,具體檢視學界,也就是學者自身所處場域。 布赫迪厄透過分析醫學院、法學院、文學院以及自然科學學院四大學術領域,其組成成員的社會背景及他們在人脈網絡中的角色,他們的實際活動情況與所能取得的權力地位,進而直剖法國高等教育長久以來的問題。藉由檢視法國數十年來的高等教育問題,看出一九六八年五月的高等教育危機如何發生,及其後學界如何變化。 布赫迪厄在書中所談的問題,雖然時空背景與今不同,但其中人的出身與隱形資源造就將來社會位置的差異,以及人們對於醫學院、法學院、文學院以及自然科學學院四大領域所能帶來的身份地位象徵,這類的問題直到今日仍非常相似,也使《學術人》於今仍具有高度參考性,不僅是一本重要的社會學研究著作,更是理解當代社會階級問題與高等教育僵化情況不能錯過的重要著作。
Read
July 13, 2020
布迪厄对学术界的分析。依然是在权利场域的框架下,和《艺术的法则》别无二致:由一系列的对立(出身背景、机构附属、教育背景等等)组合来占据学术界空间内的空间位置(第二章)。且不说内生性的问题,这个场域如何维系呢?它和相邻场域是什么关系?它内部的结构、层级是为什么出现的?写的最好的还是对权利的描写(第三章)。布迪厄貌似没有和70年代开始美国的职业研究有任何对话。不乏闪光的地方,而且例子相当有趣。
法国 社会学 职业社会学 高等教育