读过《Chinese Grammatology》 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌕
好像算是第一本完整读过的英文专著。/刚刚一点点关掉了写作时用的网页和论文,才发现自己这十天里走了好多路啊,许多新知。/知道为何欧美学者平均几年才能写出来一本书了,太扎实了。为了写书评,听两遍,中英文各读一遍,写评论的时候回顾再简单过一遍,算五遍吧。
真是好书,语言流畅、框架宏大、选题新颖、讨论细致丰富,对各种理论和相关思潮的腭引申恰到好处,收放自如。
不过确实有些地方的讨论还不够完全,有点浅尝辄止(比如第二章讨论三个思潮对拉丁化的影响)。
总而言之,这本书回答了我很多很多关于中国现代语言问题的困惑,在知识上堪称非常有用;而它的写作方式和论文框架,无疑构建了一个优秀研究的典型,让我不断地思考应当如何构建自己的文章框架。语言诗意优美。总之,瑕不掩瑜,一个学者的才华和机锋,真是隐藏不住的
Book
Chinese Grammatology
Douban
Yurou Zhong
publishing house:
Columbia University Press
2019
- 11
Today, Chinese characters are described as a national treasure, the core of the nation’s civilizational identity. Yet for nearly half of the twentieth century, reformers waged war on the Chinese script. They declared it an archaic hindrance to modernization, portraying the ancient system of writing as a roadblock to literacy and therefore science and democracy. Movements spanning the political spectrum proposed abandonment of characters and alphabetization of Chinese writing, although in the end the Communist Party opted for character simplification.
Chinese Grammatology traces the origins, transmutations, and containment of this script revolution to provide a groundbreaking account of its formative effects on Chinese literature and culture, and lasting implications for the encounter between the alphabetic and nonalphabet worlds. Yurou Zhong explores the growth of competing Romanization and Latinization movements aligned with the clashing Nationalists and Communists. She finds surprising affinities between alphabetic reform and modern Chinese literary movements and examines the politics of literacy programs and mass education against the backdrop of war and revolution. Zhong places the Chinese script revolution in the global context of a phonocentric dominance that privileges phonetic writing, contending that the eventual retention of characters constituted an anti-ethnocentric, anti-imperial critique that coincided with postwar decolonization movements and predated the emergence of Deconstructionism. By revealing the consequences of one of the biggest linguistic experiments in history, Chinese Grammatology provides an ambitious rethinking of the origins of Chinese literary modernity and the politics of the science of writing.