• NeoDB
  • Explore
  • Feed
  • Home
    • Scan barcode
    • Sign up or login
    • Preferences
8yr 有礼卡
cover
Authoritarian Legality in China [Book] Douban
author: Mary E. Gallagher publishing house: 劍橋大學出版社 2017 - 8
Can authoritarian regimes use democratic institutions to strengthen and solidify their rule? The Chinese government has legislated some of the most protective workplace laws in the world and opened up the judicial system to adjudicate workplace conflict, emboldening China's workers to use these laws. This book examines these patterns of legal mobilization, showing which workers are likely to avail themselves of these new protections and find them effective. Gallagher finds that workers with high levels of education are far more likely to claim these new rights and be satisfied with the results. However, many others, left disappointed with the large gap between law on the books and law in reality, reject the courtroom for the streets. Using workers' narratives, surveys, and case studies of protests, Gallagher argues that China's half-hearted attempt at rule of law construction undermines the stability of authoritarian rule. New workplace rights fuel workers' rising expectations, but a dysfunctional legal system drives many workers to more extreme options, including strikes, demonstrations and violence.

读过《Authoritarian Legality in China》 🌕🌕🌕🌑🌑
仔细看了看有点失望。首先,书里的资料是过时的,可以看得出来作者的田野主要是在2008年之前做的,关于工人怎么运用法律的资料主要来源于2008年前的访谈和调查,到现在十几年间的变化无法体现。其次,感觉在对工人抗争的事件描述上存在cherry picking的嫌疑。对照clb的事件叙述都能找到出入。最后,作者把不同地域混在一起讲。对于工人的法律运用主要来自2008年之前的上海,对于工人集体抗争的资料来自2008年之后的广东,然后把两个地区的故事混在一起讲了一个中国的故事。这样混淆时间地域的做法让人怀疑最后的结论。

有礼卡
@thououtsiders@neodb.social
81 following  ·  91 followers

liminal, nowhere, and able to write



关注我们建议反馈站点公约 About API Apps
You are visiting an alternative domain for NeoDB, please always use original version if possible.