社会学
Measuring Culture
Douban
John W. Mohr / Christopher A. Bail … publishing house: Columbia University Press 2020 - 7
Social scientists seek to develop systematic ways to understand how people make meaning and how the meanings they make shape them and the world in which they live. But how do we measure such processes? Measuring Culture is an essential point of entry for both those new to the field and those who are deeply immersed in the measurement of meaning. Written collectively by a team of leading qualitative and quantitative sociologists of culture, the book considers three common subjects of measurement—people, objects, and relationships—and then discusses how to pivot effectively between subjects and methods. Measuring Culture takes the reader on a tour of the state of the art in measuring meaning, from discussions of neuroscience to computational social science. It provides both the definitive introduction to the sociological literature on culture as well as a critical set of case studies for methods courses across the social sciences.
The Natural History of Revolution
Douban
Lyford P. Edwards publishing house: University of Chicago Press 1970
Read
Feb. 18, 2021
另一本被遗忘的好书,在那个年代(1927)实属有远见。不过自从斯考切波之后就没有再读它了。我手上那本港大图书馆的藏书(70年的再版),图书卡上只有两条记录。
社会学 历史社会学
The General Sociology of Harrison C. White
Douban
G. Reza Azarian publishing house: Palgrave Macmillan 2006 - 4
Harrison C. White is one of American sociology's preeminent thinkers, yet until now his endeavour to develop a general theoretical perspective on the basis of social network analysis has remained largely unexamined. This book opens out for the first time White's contribution to those interested generally in his social network approach, but daunted by the complexity and mathematical modelling often employed in his published work. Special attention is paid to White's model of production markets, as an application of his general sociology. The book draws on interview material with White himself, as well as with several of his past students.
Read
Feb. 7, 2021
怀特是战后美国最具创造力的社会学家之一,也一定并列最难懂的那几位(Identity and Control至今没读完)。这本书算是明白易懂。怀特的洞见:社会现实的网络特质以及空缺链的普适性,很大程度上来自他根本没从古典社会学里汲取什么(他的博士论文没有引用三巨头中的任何一位),相反他的灵感来自物理(他的第一个博士学位在MIT,是理论物理)以及古典人类学(他本科时候就对人类学田野工作很有兴趣)。但这也在后来给他的理论工作带来很多问题(比方在结构理论之外,他的实质性社会关系理论,以及社会本体论的缺席)。有意思的是虽然他自认是结构论者,但Randall Collins(前言写的特别好)和本书作者都认为「过程论」是他理论的底色。和芝加哥的互动论者不同,怀特版本(容我发挥)是微观粒子永不停歇运动的世界
社会学 社会理论 数学社会学 传记
Imagined Futures
Douban
Jens Beckert publishing house: Harvard University Press 2016 - 6
In a capitalist system, consumers, investors, and corporations orient their activities toward a future that contains opportunities and risks. How actors assess uncertainty is a problem that economists have tried to solve through general equilibrium and rational expectations theory. Powerful as these analytical tools are, they underestimate the future’s unknowability by assuming that markets, in the aggregate, correctly forecast what is to come. Jens Beckert adds a new chapter to the theory of capitalism by demonstrating how fictional expectations drive modern economies—or throw them into crisis when the imagined futures fail to materialize. Collectively held images of how the future will unfold are critical because they free economic actors from paralyzing doubt, enabling them to commit resources and coordinate decisions even if those expectations prove inaccurate. Beckert distinguishes fictional expectations from performativity theory, which holds that predictions tend to become self-fulfilling prophecies. Economic forecasts are important not because they produce the futures they envision but because they create the expectations that generate economic activity in the first place. Actors pursue money, investments, innovations, and consumption only if they believe the objects obtained through market exchanges will retain value. We accept money because we believe in its future purchasing power. We accept the risk of capital investments and innovation because we expect profit. And we purchase consumer goods based on dreams of satisfaction. As Imagined Futures shows, those who ignore the role of real uncertainty and fictional expectations in market dynamics misunderstand the nature of capitalism.
Read
Jan. 31, 2021
简言之,就是「真·画大饼原理」。玩笑除外,Bekckert这本是集大成之作:经济学(Shackle),实用主义哲学(杜威),和社会学(欠缺)里关于不确定性的研究置于资本主义动态的视角下。写得很「磅礴」——从Frank Knight,大卫·哈维,布迪厄,到格雷伯,一应俱全。除了理论框架(不是他的原创,但肯定是他非常系统地articulate),四个实证章节也很有启发(货币/债务、投资、创新、消费)。9、10 两章知识哲学方面的企图不敢说我很接受,但有意思。
社会学 经济社会学 资本主义 时间性 不确定性
Decision Order and Time in Human Affairs
Douban
G. L. S. Shackle publishing house: 劍橋大學出版社 2010 - 5
Originally published in 1969, the second edition of Professor Shackle's book has a fresh preface, an extra chapter and a number of additions to its bibliography. The extra chapter is concerned with the point at which one would decide to abandon an old policy and replace it with a new one. It is, in the words of the author, a further, rather radical development of the Stockholm sequence analysis. Professor Shackle examines how a decision can be rational only in a special sense, that of exploiting to the best present effect, on the decision-maker's state of mind, the scope afforded to imagination by what is known and by the gaps in that knowledge. The attempt made in this book to provide a theory of such decision has been called 'an existentialist economics'.
Read
Jan. 31, 2021
遗世佳作(1960初版),把时间性带入经济学的先驱。文笔优美。「For the the living individual, there is but one moment -- the present. Within this same solitary moment-in-being must lie all the *actual* consequences in view of which any decision is taken in that moment. ... Such consequences, to be *relevant* for decision; must be experiences *by imagination*」
经济学 时间性 不确定性 社会学
Administrative Behavior, 4th Edition
Douban
Herbert A. Simon publishing house: Free Press 1997 - 3
Description In this fourth edition of his ground-breaking work, Herbert A. Simon applies his pioneering theory of human choice and administrative decision-making to concrete organizational problems. To commemorate the fiftieth anniversary of the book's original publication, Professor Simon enhances his timeless observations on the human decision-making process with commentaries examining new facets of organizational behavior. Investigating the impact of changing social values and modem technology on the operation of organizations, the new ideas featured in this revised edition update a book that has become a worldwide classic. Named by Public Administration Review as "Book of the Half Century," Administrative Behavior is considered one of the most influential books on social science thinking, and was referred to by the Nobel Committee as "epoch-making." Written for managers and other professionals who wish to understand the decision-making processes at the heart of organization and management, it is also essential reading for students in business and management, economics, sociology, psychology computer science, government, and law. Find out more: Read an excerpt Book Information Free Press, March 1997 Hardcover, 384 pages ISBN-10: 0-684-83582-7 ISBN-13: 978-0-684-83582-2
Read
Jan. 29, 2021
「还有许多我只吸收了一句话、一道目光的人,只是作为个体的人我已记不起来了。一部作品便是一片广阔的墓地,大多数墓碑上的名字已被磨去,无法再辨认。」
社会学 管理理论 组织研究
The Explanation of Social Action
Douban
John Levi Martin publishing house: Oxford University Press, USA 2011 - 8
Conventional understanding of what it means to "explain" something in the social sciences provokes unnecessary confusion and conflict, and indeed is often based more on analysts' imaginations than actors' realities. The Explanation of Social Action lays out a sustained critique of this understanding, pointing out that the root of the problem is an attempt to counterpose two radically different types of answers to the question of why someone did a certain thing--first person responses and third person ones. John Levi Martin illustrates how this tendency is epitomized in attempts to explain human action in "causal" terms. He shows how this causality has little to do with the real world, but instead involves the creation of imaginary worlds, stemming from an intellectual history whereby social scientists began to distrust the self-understanding of actors and accepted fundamentally anti-democratic epistemologies, due to an epistemic hiatus in social knowledge and the adoption of practices in the intensely hierarchic setting of forced incarceral institutions for the insane. Martin moves on to highlight other traditions that do not assume that the cognitive schemes of actors are fundamentally arbitrary. These traditions in turn suggest that the analytic problems that now arise require attention to the nature of judgment, implying the need for an understanding of the process whereby actors intuit intersubjectively valid qualities of complex social objects. Tackling the very way in which social scientists analyze why people do things, The Explanation of Social Action is a novel and essential take on the evidence on which their explanations are based.
Read
Jan. 20, 2021
毋庸置疑的tour de force,比第一本书又上了一个台阶。我很喜欢第五章,非常有启发性(佛洛伊德-涂尔干/皮亚杰-维谷斯基/格式塔/杜威),值得反复体会。其它章节也对当代社会科学哲学/方法论有深刻的见解。基本上所有当代的方法论争论他都涉及到了。JLM的写作风格对新手很不友好(爱掉书袋,自己想法多,喜欢一句话没写完用括号继续平行第二句)。我的一个感觉是这本书,在没有对其中某个领域有一定经验之前,没法单独看。JLM不把自己跟某个学派捆绑,既有优点(正反都能写给读者看)也让人觉得有点遗憾(掰开之后怎么办?)。在前言里还藏了个梗,未免搞笑心思太重!
社会学 社会科学哲学 研究方法
Kingdom of Children
Douban
Mitchell L. Stevens publishing house: Princeton University Press 2001
More than one million American children are schooled by their parents. As their ranks grow, home schoolers are making headlines by winning national spelling bees and excelling at elite universities. The few studies conducted suggest that homeschooled children are academically successful and remarkably well socialized. Yet we still know little about this alternative to one of society’s most fundamental institutions. Beyond a vague notion of children reading around the kitchen table, we don’t know what home schooling looks like from the inside. Sociologist Mitchell Stevens goes behind the scenes of the homeschool movement and into the homes and meetings of home schoolers. What he finds are two very different kinds of home education—one rooted in the liberal alternative school movement of the 1960s and 1970s and one stemming from the Christian day school movement of the same era. Stevens explains how this dual history shapes the meaning and practice of home schooling today. In the process, he introduces us to an unlikely mix of parents (including fundamentalist Protestants, pagans, naturalists, and educational radicals) and notes the core values on which they agree: the sanctity of childhood and the primacy of family in the face of a highly competitive, bureaucratized society. Kingdom of Children aptly places home schoolers within longer traditions of American social activism. It reveals that home schooling is not a random collection of individuals but an elaborate social movement with its own celebrities, networks, and characteristic lifeways. Stevens shows how home schoolers have built their philosophical and religious convictions into the practical structure of the cause, and documents the political consequences of their success at doing so. Ultimately, the history of home schooling serves as a parable about the organizational strategies of the progressive left and the religious right since the 1960s.Kingdom of Children shows what happens when progressive ideals meet conventional politics, demonstrates the extraordinary political capacity of conservative Protestantism, and explains the subtle ways in which cultural sensibility shapes social movement outcomes more generally.
Read
Jan. 19, 2021
作者的博士论文,写的是1990年代HS运动。他认为HS是一场社会运动,有一个文化结构(60年代以降的expanded self)配合美国独特的教育市场(分散)、偏向于个体自由的法律环境,还有结合一批关注个体的教育意识形态,当然,还有契合宗教右翼的主张。我觉得不好的地方是正好夹在民族志和历史叙事的中间。他的个体材料跟整体论点之间联系很薄弱。最后,想想中国今天的育儿市场:蒙台梭利、Emilia Reggio、华德福——每一个都能在HS运动里找到他们的身影。想来这个理念能引起很大的共鸣。
社会学 教育社会学 美国 社会运动
The Institution of Science and the Science of Institutions
Douban
Marcel Herbst publishing house: Springer 2014
The present anthology, edited by Marcel Herbst, is partially based on a conference, held in 2009, to reflect on the legacy of Ben-David, and contains a selection of substantially revised papers, plus four contributions specifically written for this volume. The book focuses on three major lines of Ben-David’s research, namely “Center and Periphery” (Part I), “Role and Ethos” (Part II), and “Organization and Growth” (Part III). In addition, comprehensive introductory (“Prologue”) and concluding chapters  (“Epilogue”, Part IV) by Marcel Herbst are provided. The volume addresses the following disciplines: higher education, history and sociology of science, philosophy of science, history of medicine, public administration, policy studies, Jewish studies, and economics. The anthology is one of two new publications on Joseph Ben-David after the special Minerva edition Vol. 25, Numbers 1–2, March 1987,  and Gad Freudenthal’s collection of Ben-David’s writings [1991]. The text can be used in graduate studies, it addresses higher education professionals or public officials, and serves as a gateway to researchers in the field of higher education, science studies, or policy sciences.
The Unfree Professions
Douban
Konrad Hugo Jarausch publishing house: Oxford University Press, USA 1990 - 9
How could educated professionals have supported the Nazi movement and collaborated with Hitler's inhuman policies? Jarausch examines this fascinating and largely unexplored subject, tracing the social, ideological, and political development of three representative German professions--law, teaching, and engineering--from the late Empire to the early Federal Republic. Based on a reformulated professionalization theory and on authoritative statistics, he describes professional prosperity and prestige in the Second Reich and analyzes the social crisis brought on by hyperinflation, stabilization, and Depression during the chaotic Weimar years. Threatened with the loss of livelihood and frightened by cultural disorientation, many experts embraced neo-conservative ideas and cooperated in Hitler's seizure of power. Welcoming the apparent restoration of their authority in the early Third Reich, professionals collaborated in the racial purges and warping of ethics, practices, and organizations under Nazi rule. During the Second World War, the radicalization of SS terror threatened the very survival of the professions so that most practitioners were only too happy to be rescued by Allied victory. Exploring the reluctant democratization of the post-war professions, Jarausch concludes with a reflection on the lessons of the German experience for the relationship between professionalism and liberty.
Read
Jan. 14, 2021
80年代的产物,把理想的「职业」对标英美的社会学文献,认为德国的「职业化」是十八世纪到十九世纪中产阶级形成最骄傲的成果(p226),就我感兴趣的教师问题,第一章最好。三个职业在政治光谱占据不同位置(律师liberal、教师national,工程师indifferent),最终都在纳粹德国时期被帝国吸收。作者认为德国职业化可以用新法团主义来概括,单就从叙事的角度来说说得过去,可是和同时代的生态论点一比就着实觉得缺乏动态。
职业社会学 社会学 史学 德国史 二战
The Child's Conception of the World
Douban
Jean Piaget translator: Andrew Tomlinson publishing house: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers 2007 - 9
A milestone of child psychology, The Child's Conception of the World explores the ways in which the reasoning powers of young children differ from those of adults. What conceptions of the world does the child naturally form at the different stages of its development? To what extent does the child distinguish the external world from an internal or subjective world and what limits does he or she draw between the self and objective reality? These questions make up the first problem, the child's notion of reality. A second fundamental problem is the significance of explanations put forward by the child. What use does he or she make of the notions of cause and law? Is the form of explanation presented by the child a new type? These and like questions form the second problem, the child's notion of causality. Jacques Voneche, Director of the Piaget Archives in Geneva, Switzerland, provides a preface to this classic in which he reveals the provanance of The Child's Conception of the World within the context of Piaget's other work and the then-burgeoning field of developmental psychology.
Read
Jan. 13, 2021
1926年成书(法文),29年译成英文。皮亚杰的第二本书,当时他30岁,了不起的杰作!用心理学的方法研究儿童的现实观(他称之为实在论,但更像是建构主义),结论基于三重的二元论(p.86),分析非常精妙(第二章,称之为科幻也不为过)。后面的扩展案例:梦境、魔法(!)、泛灵论,artificialism,每一章都异常精彩。
社会学 儿童 心理学 身心理论 学习理论
Gifted Tongues
Douban
Fine, Gary Alan publishing house: Princeton University Press 2001 - 5
Learning to argue and persuade in a highly competitive environment is only one aspect of life on a high-school debate team. Teenage debaters also participate in a distinct cultural world--complete with its own jargon and status system--in which they must negotiate complicated relationships with teammates, competitors, coaches, and parents as well as classmates outside the debating circuit. In Gifted Tongues, Gary Alan Fine offers a rich description of this world as a testing ground for both intellectual and emotional development, while seeking to understand adolescents as social actors. Considering the benefits and drawbacks of the debating experience, he also recommends ways of reshaping programs so that more high schools can use them to boost academic performance and foster specific skills in citizenship. Fine analyzes the training of debaters in rapid-fire speech, rules of logical argumentation, and the strategic use of evidence, and how this training instills the core values of such American institutions as law and politics. Debates, however, sometimes veer quickly from fine displays of logic to acts of immaturity--a reflection of the tensions experienced by young people learning to think as adults. Fine contributes to our understanding of teenage years by encouraging us not to view them as a distinct stage of development but rather a time in which young people draw from a toolkit of both childlike and adult behaviors. A well-designed debate program, he concludes, nurtures the intellect while providing a setting in which teens learn to make better behavioral choices, ones that will shape relationships in their personal, professional, and civic lives.
Read
Jan. 12, 2021
辩论(更确切的说,argumentation)和美国文化的关系写的很好(p39-41),它既不是创造真理,也不简单是一种游戏。在规则之下生成了一种局部的「证据」,供参赛者们不断练习。可惜的是没看到辩手们和规则的互动,写的比较平铺直叙。最后,看到「文化作为一种工具箱」,我乐了。
社会学 青少年 教育社会学 教育
Social Structures
Douban
John Levi Martin publishing house: Princeton University Press 2009 - 8
Social Structures is a book that examines how structural forms spontaneously arise from social relationships. Offering major insights into the building blocks of social life, it identifies which locally emergent structures have the capacity to grow into larger ones and shows how structural tendencies associated with smaller structures shape and constrain patterns of larger structures. The book then investigates the role such structures have played in the emergence of the modern nation-state. Bringing together the latest findings in sociology, anthropology, political science, and history, John Levi Martin traces how sets of interpersonal relationships become ordered in different ways to form structures. He looks at a range of social structures, from smaller ones like families and street gangs to larger ones such as communes and, ultimately, nation-states. He finds that the relationships best suited to forming larger structures are those that thrive in conditions of inequality; that are incomplete and as sparse as possible, and thereby avoid the problem of completion in which interacting members are required to establish too many relationships; and that abhor transitivity rather than assuming it. Social Structures argues that these "patronage" relationships, which often serve as means of loose coordination in the absence of strong states, are nevertheless the scaffolding of the social structures most distinctive to the modern state, namely the command army and the political party.
Read
Jan. 11, 2021
JLM的第一本书,野心大,视野宽,旁征博引(从历史社会学到数学社会学啥都有)。写的很散,所有的社会结构他都想解释一番。语言上绝对没现在那么调皮,能够做到高度形式化又不依赖数学语言,很不容易。但就是一板一眼,不想让人全文读第二遍的书……但是讨论involution,transitivity这样的概念依然让人叫绝。
社会学 形式化分析 社会结构
Situated Learning
Douban Goodreads
Jean Lave / Etienne Wenger publishing house: 劍橋大學出版社 1991 - 9
In this important theoretical treatist, Jean Lave, anthropologist, and Etienne Wenger, computer scientist, push forward the notion of situated learning - that learning is fundamentally a social process. The authors maintain that learning viewed as situated activity has as its central defining characteristic a process they call legitimate peripheral participation (LPP). Learners participate in communities of practitioners, moving toward full participation in the sociocultural practices of a community. LPP provides a way to speak about crucial relations between newcomers and old-timers and about their activities, identities, artefacts, knowledge and practice. The communities discussed in the book are midwives, tailors, quartermasters, butchers, and recovering alcoholics, however, the process by which participants in those communities learn can be generalised to other social groups.
Read
Jan. 10, 2021
LPP的概念非常吸引人,难怪人人都要引用。我觉得有意思的地方还在于提供了一个比较社会结构的视角来理解学习。写的短小精悍。要说不满的话,就是对于实践共同体的结构,知识和技能的定义都很浅显。毕竟要用屠夫剁肉(还不是庖丁那种)和裁缝做衣服来类比学术知识好像有那么点别扭。可换个角度,作为个人如何被实践共同体接纳,这个角度来看,也未尝不可。这本书催生了一大批研究,接下来好好看一下。
学习理论 教育社会学 社会学
The Joyful Community
Douban
Benjamin Zablocki publishing house: Penguin Books 1971
Read
Jan. 9, 2021
当代宗教社群研究。让人不禁想,我们创造出的那些非常「纯粹」的社会结构,是不是只是意味着再一次重复之前所发生的一切?
社会学 宗教
Articulating Citizenship
Douban
罗伯特·卡尔普 publishing house: Harvard University Asia Center 2007 - 11
At the genesis of the Republic of China in 1912, many political leaders, educators, and social reformers argued that republican education should transform China's people into dynamic modern citizens--social and political agents whose public actions would rescue the national community. Over subsequent decades, however, they came to argue fiercely over the contents of citizenship and how it should be taught. Moreover, many of their carefully crafted policies and programs came to be transformed by textbook authors, teachers, administrators, and students. Furthermore, the idea of citizenship, once introduced, raised many troubling questions. Who belonged to the national community in China, and how was the nation constituted? What were the best modes of political action? How should modern people take responsibility for "public matters"? What morality was proper for the modern public? This book reconstructs civic education and citizenship training in secondary schools in the lower Yangzi region during the Republican era. It also analyzes how students used the tools of civic education introduced in their schools to make themselves into young citizens and explores the complex social and political effects of educated youths' civic action.
Becoming Adult
Douban
Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi / Barbara Schneider publishing house: Basic Books 2001 - 4
How do young people envision their occupational futures? What do teenagers feel about their schooling and after-school work, and how do these experiences affect their passage to adult work? These are the questions that psychologist Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi and sociologist Barbara Schneider posed in their five-year study of adolescents. The results provide an unprecedented window on society's future through which we can glimpse how today's youth are preparing themselves for the lives they will lead in the decades to come.
Read
Dec. 30, 2020
毕业时候从老师办公室拿的(她是作者之一),一直没看。作为90年代大规模社会调查的一部分,非常normal science。甚至连理论框架也没有——不管读者是否相信,基金会对于这类好读的作品愿意投钱。从某些方面来看,这是很有潜力的作品:通过把主观经验客观化,能开拓很多新的研究可能性,ESM方法显然拥有这种可能,但是限制其解释力的恰恰是对于个体经验狭义的操作化。结构性因素如何影响年轻人是通过每天8次记录时间用途可以回答的吗?微观的或者偶然的因素如何推动大的决策,这是普遍状态还是某种特例?这些问题都被扫到一边去了,最后就变成「另一项青少年研究」罢了。
社会学 青年研究
Complex Adaptive Systems
Douban
John H. Miller / Scott E. Page publishing house: Princeton University Press 2007 - 3
This book provides the first clear, comprehensive, and accessible account of complex adaptive social systems, by two of the field's leading authorities. Such systems - whether political parties, stock markets, or ant colonies - present some of the most intriguing theoretical and practical challenges confronting the social sciences. Engagingly written, and balancing technical detail with intuitive explanations, "Complex Adaptive Systems" focuses on the key tools and ideas that have emerged in the field since the mid-1990s, as well as the techniques needed to investigate such systems. It provides a detailed introduction to concepts such as emergence, self-organized criticality, automata, networks, diversity, adaptation, and feedback. It also demonstrates how complex adaptive systems can be explored using methods ranging from mathematics to computational models of adaptive agents. John Miller and Scott Page show how to combine ideas from economics, political science, biology, physics, and computer science to illuminate topics in organization, adaptation, decentralization, and robustness. They also demonstrate how the usual extremes used in modeling can be fruitfully transcended.
Read
Dec. 6, 2020
写得还挺好的一本用形式化方法阐述computation as social theory的书。蛮有趣的。杂感:形式化的书很容易写出民科感来。不是说这本书不好,只是读到「八正道框架」(第七章)的时候还感觉挺诈唬的。有趣的是学科似乎从来不与这些学者对话,或者说我还没观察到两者是如何互动的。比方说怎么处理偶然性?怎么处理micro-macro linkage?怎么处理时间性?或者在计算框架内,怎么理解优化?怎么理解局部收敛和协调?路很宽广。
复杂系统 社会学 形式化方法 方法论
Degrees of Control
Douban
David K. Brown publishing house: Teachers College, Columbia University 1949
Read
Nov. 23, 2020
很可惜这本书被引用的很少。继承并发扬了柯林斯的理论框架基础,在微观层面叙事上更近一层。相比「文化货币」,Brown的「理性化职业需求」更符合直觉。
社会学 教育社会学 历史 高等教育
文凭社会
The Credential Society Douban Goodreads
★ 7.9 17 ratings
[美]兰德尔·柯林斯 translator: 刘冉 publishing house: 北京大学出版社 2018 - 6
本书通过追溯19世纪下半叶到20世纪70年代晚期一百多年来的美国教育发展历史,主要以医学、法律和工程学教育为例,剖析了文凭社会是如何形成的、对社会产生的正面和负面影响,展现了文凭异化的过程,解释了学校教育与社会分层的内在关系,进而完成了对当代资本主义教育制度的反思和批判,最后则提出了化解文凭主义弊端的办法,预测了文凭主义在未来社会中的处境。 作者针砭时弊,揭穿了关于教育的诸多神话,认为建立在教育基础之上的文凭社会是一种不合理的分层机制,建议废除文凭。在当下这个文凭社会的势力越来越强的时代,书中内容有助于我们更好地理解当前面临的诸多教育问题,积极思谋应对之策。
Read
Nov. 18, 2020
托中文版的福,复习了一下柯林斯的论点。原来没注意到他在第六章里提出的是一个「职业霸权」论点(具体案例,如医生和工程师,是否可信还需要更多时间核实原始数据;不过在70年代这确实是一种主流论述),这个论点再嫁接到文化分层上面。
教育社会学 社会学