社会学
Signs of Difference
Douban
Susan Gal / Judith T. Irvine publishing house: 劍橋大學出版社 2019 - 8
How are peoples' ideas about languages, ways of speaking and expressive styles shaped by their social positions and values? How is difference, in language and in social life, made - and unmade? How and why are some differences persuasive as the basis for action, while other differences are ignored or erased? Written by two recognised authorities on language and culture, this book argues that ideological work of all kinds is fundamentally communicative, and that social positions, projects and historical moments influence, and are influenced by, people's ideas about communicative practices. Neither true nor false, ideologies are positioned and partial visions of the world, relying on comparison and perspective; they exploit differences in expressive features - linguistic and otherwise - to construct convincing stereotypes of people, spaces and activities. Using detailed ethnographic, historical and contemporary examples, this outstanding book shows readers how to analyse ideological work semiotically.
Read
Aug. 10, 2020
有洞见,用皮尔士的符号理论来理解「语言-意识形态」——在作者的体系里一个中性概念,是某一类的观点(partial views)。两位认为这些partials通过contrast和perspective通过一套符号系统(依赖rhematization, fractal recursivity,erasure等机制)组合为一个世界观,由种种value differences组成。然后在此之上还讨论了时间和地点的偶然性——芝加哥学派的标志。光机制的部分相当有意思。缺点也挺明显:1)实证材料五花八门,拼凑感强(c2民族志来自70年代末到90年代;c3-5各种迷你分析;c6-7更当代的例子;c9历史分析)。2)术语爆炸(4-5章眼花缭乱)。每一章拆开都棒,合起来就差了些。要多读皮尔士才能更好地理解。
符号理论 互动 人类学 社会学 意识形态研究
To Dwell among Friends
Douban
Claude S. Fischer publishing house: University Of Chicago Press 1982 - 4
Read
Aug. 7, 2020
仔细扎实不浮夸,关于社区的个人体验,也是关于社会网络——在形式化方法开始大行其道之前。Problemtizing the obvious: 与小镇相比城市生活并没有改变个人关系,而是带来了不同的形式。封面可能是我读过社会学书里最可爱的了吧。
美国 社区研究 都市社会学 社会学
Professional Dominance
Douban
Eliot Freidson publishing house: Aldine Transaction 2006
Read
Aug. 13, 2020
虽然被认为是「前范式」下的作品,但今天读起来依然写的非常帮。清晰、精准,还有文采(第二章多棒)。分工、控制市场准入、职业同侪间的社会化的见地现在一点都不过时。jurisdiction这个词应该是从这里来的吧?
医学社会学 职业社会学 社会学
The Unfree Professions
Douban
Konrad Hugo Jarausch publishing house: Oxford University Press, USA 1990 - 9
How could educated professionals have supported the Nazi movement and collaborated with Hitler's inhuman policies? Jarausch examines this fascinating and largely unexplored subject, tracing the social, ideological, and political development of three representative German professions--law, teaching, and engineering--from the late Empire to the early Federal Republic. Based on a reformulated professionalization theory and on authoritative statistics, he describes professional prosperity and prestige in the Second Reich and analyzes the social crisis brought on by hyperinflation, stabilization, and Depression during the chaotic Weimar years. Threatened with the loss of livelihood and frightened by cultural disorientation, many experts embraced neo-conservative ideas and cooperated in Hitler's seizure of power. Welcoming the apparent restoration of their authority in the early Third Reich, professionals collaborated in the racial purges and warping of ethics, practices, and organizations under Nazi rule. During the Second World War, the radicalization of SS terror threatened the very survival of the professions so that most practitioners were only too happy to be rescued by Allied victory. Exploring the reluctant democratization of the post-war professions, Jarausch concludes with a reflection on the lessons of the German experience for the relationship between professionalism and liberty.
Read
Jan. 14, 2021
80年代的产物,把理想的「职业」对标英美的社会学文献,认为德国的「职业化」是十八世纪到十九世纪中产阶级形成最骄傲的成果(p226),就我感兴趣的教师问题,第一章最好。三个职业在政治光谱占据不同位置(律师liberal、教师national,工程师indifferent),最终都在纳粹德国时期被帝国吸收。作者认为德国职业化可以用新法团主义来概括,单就从叙事的角度来说说得过去,可是和同时代的生态论点一比就着实觉得缺乏动态。
教师教育 职业社会学 社会学 教育社会学 二战
割据的逻辑
Douban
刘思达 publishing house: 译林出版社 2017 - 10
本书将芝加哥社会学派的生态分析传统引入对中国法律职业的实证研究当中,在详细梳理了法律服务行业的源起和变迁之后,又搭建了相当宏大的理论体系,以解释行业内部和外部各种边界的产生。该体系还原了职业者与政府、社会和其他职业者之间的多元互动,在保存了复杂性的前提之下,极为精准地将这些互动抽象为“合界”、“分界”、“维界”与“共生交换”几种基础行为模式。此书堪称中国法律社会学的典范之作,值得所有法学研究者仔细阅读。增订本收入了《方庭的窗口:芝大留学往事》和《场域与生态》两篇文章。
Habits of the Heart
Douban
Robert N. Bellah / Richard Madsen … publishing house: University of California Press 2007 - 9
First published in 1985, "Habits of the Heart" continues to be one of the most discussed interpretations of modern American society, a quest for a democratic community that draws on our diverse civic and religious traditions. In a new preface the authors relate the arguments of the book both to the current realities of American society and to the growing debate about the country's future. With this new edition one of the most influential books of recent times takes on a new immediacy.
School Principal
Douban
Dan C. Lortie publishing house: University Of Chicago Press 2009 - 5
When we think about school principals, most of us imagine a figure of vague, yet intimidating authority - for an elementary school student, being sent to the principal's office is roughly on par with a trip to Orwell's Room 101. But with "School Principal", Dan C. Lortie aims to change that. Much as he did for teachers with his groundbreaking book "Schoolteacher", Lortie offers here an intensive and detailed look at principals, painting a compelling portrait of what they do, how they do it, and why. Lortie begins with a brief history of the job before turning to the daily work of a principal. These men and women, he finds, stand at the center of a constellation of competing interests around and within the school. School district officials, teachers, parents, and students all have needs and demands that frequently clash, and it is the principal's job to manage these conflicting expectations to best serve the public. Unsurprisingly then, Lortie records his subjects' professional dissatisfactions, but he also vividly depicts the pleasures of their work and the pride they take in their accomplishments. Finally, "School Principal" offers a glimpse of the future with an analysis of current issues and trends in education, including the increasing presence of women in the role and the effects of widespread testing mandated by the government. Lortie's scope is both broad and deep, offering an eminently useful range of perspectives on his subject. From the day-to-day toil to the long-term course of an entire career, from finding out just what goes on inside that office to mapping out the larger social and organizational context of the job, "School Principal" is a truly comprehensive account of a little-understood profession.
科学革命的结构
The Structure of Scientific Revolutions Google Books Douban
★ 9.0 56 ratings
[美]托马斯·库恩 / [美]伊安·哈金 (导读) translator: 金吾伦 / 胡新和 publishing house: 北京大学出版社 2012 - 11
本书是20世纪学术史上最有影响的著作之一,是科学史与科学哲学研究的学者们不可不读的基本文献。它引导了科学哲学界的一场认识论的大变革,成为科学哲学史上一道重要的分水岭。其影响不仅在于科学史、科学哲学、科学社会学等相关领域,而且延伸到社会学、文化人类学、文学史、艺术史、政治 史、宗教史等人文和社会科学领域,甚至在社会公众领域也产生了深刻的影响。书中提出的“范式转换”一语如今已成为我们耳熟能详的一个重要词汇。本书自1962年面世以来就引起强烈反响,掀起了一股世界性的研究热潮,其影响至今不衰。本版是芝加哥大学出版社为庆祝本书问世五十周年而作,新加入加拿大哲学家伊安·哈金教授所写的导读。“自然科学的发展除了按常规科学一点一滴地积累之外,还必然要出现“科学革命”。科学革命不仅仅使科学的面貌焕然一新,而且还会引起人们世界观的变革。” - 托马斯·库恩
Exit, Voice, and Loyalty
Google Books Douban Goodreads
Albert O. Hirschman publishing house: Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press 1970 - 1
An innovator in contemporary thought on economic and political development looks here at decline rather than growth. Albert O. Hirschman makes a basic distinction between alternative ways of reacting to deterioration in business firms and, in general, to dissatisfaction with organizations: one, “exit,” is for the member to quit the organization or for the customer to switch to the competing product, and the other, “voice,” is for members or customers to agitate and exert influence for change “from within.” The efficiency of the competitive mechanism, with its total reliance on exit, is questioned for certain important situations. As exit often undercuts voice while being unable to counteract decline, loyalty is seen in the function of retarding exit and of permitting voice to play its proper role. The interplay of the three concepts turns out to illuminate a wide range of economic, social, and political phenomena. As the author states in the preface, “having found my own unifying way of looking at issues as diverse as competition and the two-party system, divorce and the American character, black power and the failure of ‘unhappy’ top officials to resign over Vietnam, I decided to let myself go a little.”
文化的解释
The Interpretation of Cultures Douban
★ 9.4 7 ratings
(美)克利福德·格尔茨 translator: 韩莉 publishing house: 译林出版社 1999 - 11
简介: 格尔茨这本开拓性的著作,美国社会学协会1974年索罗金奖获奖作品,有助于为整个一代人类学家界定其领域的终极目的。 ——《出版家周刊》 前 言 当一位人类学家在殷切的出版商的催促下,着手收集他的某些论文,以便对他自离开研究生院后十五年中的工作作一个回顾性的展示时,面临着两个困难的抉择:收集哪些论文以及如何以诚实的态度来对待收集进来的论文。我们所有这些为社会科学杂志写文章的人都有一本自己想像中的非书之书(nonbook),而越来越多的人也正在把它们出版出来。我们所有的人都设想过去自己写的东西现在会写得更好,而且准备好了要自己修改而决不让编辑改动。想要从自己的行文中发现精巧的构思可能会同想在自己的生活中有所发现一样让人失望;事后(post facto)编一个进去——“这就是我过去想要说的意思”——是一种强烈的诱惑。 面对第一个抉择,我决定只收入那些与文化概念有直接而明显关系的论文。事实上,这些论文的大多数不是理论探求而是经验研究,因为当我离社会生活的直接体验太远时,我就会感到不舒服。但是所有的论文基本上都是通过一个又一个的实例,来提出一个独特的——别人也许会认为是奇怪的观点来阐明什么是文化,它在社会生活中扮演了什么角色,以及应该如何恰当地研究它。虽然重新定义文化是我作为人类学家最持久的兴趣,但是我也在经济发展、社会组织、比较史学和文化生态学领域里做了一些拓展——为了避免离题太远,本书就没有反映这些关注。因而,我希望,这一组论文看起来就像是一篇通过一系列具体分析而得来的论文,不要仅仅是一种“尔后我写道……”这样的对有些漂泊的职业生涯的回顾。这本书要进行论证。 第二个抉择不大容易处理。一般来说,我对发表过的文章采取一种stare decisis(维持原样)的态度,即使仅仅是因为如果这些论文需要很大的修改,那就完全不应该重印它们,而应代之以能纠正错误的全新论文,也应这么做。况且,把改变了的观点写进早先的著作中来纠正自己的错误判断,在我看来不太光明磊落。这样做会模糊了选编自己的论文时首先想揭示的思想发展进程。 不过,即便如此,虽然争论的实质不受严重影响,但要是对原文一字不改,传达的就是过时的信息或因与现在已淡化的一系列事件联系过于紧密而削弱了现在还有效的讨论,在这种情况下,似乎还是有正当理由,回过头去做一些校订。 在后面选收的论文中,有两处与我上面的考虑有关,因而我就对原来写的东西做了些修改。第一处是第二编中的两篇关于文化与生物进化的论文,原文给出的化石年代已被确切地替代了。这些年代,一般说是向前推了,这一变化基本上未触动我的核心论证,我认为引入比较新的测算没有坏处。在考古学已经发现四百万或五百万年前的化石后,再说南方古猿(Australopithecines )可以追溯至一百万年前就没有多少意思了。第二处与第四编第十章《整合式革命》有关,自这篇论文在本世纪六十年代写作以来,新国家历史的潮流——如果它应该这么称呼的话——已使其中的一些内容读起来很古怪。既然纳赛尔已经去世,巴基斯坦已经分裂,尼日利亚已经非封建化,共产党已从印度尼西亚的政治舞台上消失,如果写得仿佛这些事件没有发生过似的,会给讨论带来不真实的感觉,而且即使现在不是尼赫鲁而是尼赫鲁的女儿在领导印度,马来亚共和国已经扩大为马来西亚联邦,这个讨论我认为还有意义的。因此我在这篇论文中做了两类修改。第一,我变换了时态,引入了从句,添加了一两处脚注等等,从而在使论文的正文读起来不太像过去的十年没有出现过一样。但是我没有为了增强论证而改变任何实质性的东西。第二,我给每一个历史实例都增加了一段内容,概括自这篇论文写作以来与之有关的发展——而且清楚地与实例正文分开,以此来明确指出,假如有任何事件发生,它的发展显示出在这篇论文中以早先的事件为根据的讨论仍然与剔除过时事件( Rip Van Winkle)的影响有关。除了一些印刷和语法上的小更正(以及为索引风格一致所做的修改),本书的其他内容基本上没变。 不过,我增加了新的一章,即第一章,尽可能概括地表明我现在采取的立场。因为各章讨论的观点跨越十五个年头,在引论性的第一章中讨论某些事情的方式的确与出现在重印的某些其他章中的方式有些不同。我早先的一些关注——比如功能主义——现在在我的思想里已不太突出;而一些后来的关注——比如符号学——现在更突出了。但在我看来,这些论文中的思想走向是相对连贯的——它们的排列是按逻辑顺序而非年月顺序,而第一章代表的是一种努力,要更清楚、更系统地说明这一思想走向是什么:总之,努力说出我一直在说的东西。 我删掉了论文中原有的所有致谢,那些帮助过我的人知道他们帮助过我,并且也知道给我的帮助有多么大。我只能希望他们至今还知道我也知道这些帮助。而我不再忙乱地提及他们,代之以对三个出色的学术机构的真诚的感谢:哈佛大学社会关系系,我在那里受过训练;芝加哥大学人类学系,我在那里教了十年书;普林斯顿高等学术研究所,我现在在那里工作。在美国大学系统被抨击为不合潮流或日益恶化的时刻,我只能说,它 一直是一份拯救我的礼物。 (克利福德·格尔茨 一九七三年于普林斯顿)
Read
Oct. 31, 2020
念博士的时候有一天室友很兴奋的跟我讲《文化的解释》启发她观察教室老师的教学。我听了半天没明白她说的是什么,这书哪好了?翻了几页就放到书架上了。那时候我醉心的是怎么求解一组统计量。兜兜转转又拿起来仔细读了一遍,我太傻了。「快乐的是那些忘记的人,更快乐的是那些记住并深藏心底的人。」(p.131)无与伦比。
人类学 社会学
领悟方法
Thinking Through Methods: A Social Science Primer Douban
★ 9.2 13 ratings
[美] 约翰·李维·马丁 translator: 高勇 publishing house: 重庆大学出版社 2020 - 10
做社会学研究,非常不容易。如果不明了自身所做之事,不明了工作的努力方向,你就会像瓷器店里的公牛一样,必然把事情搞砸。这是约翰·李维·马丁在这本如何进行严谨的社会科学研究的书中告诫我们的,它风趣、睿智而必需。本书关注的是研究者需要进行的各种实际决策:到哪儿去找寻你所需要的资料?你所找到的资料与可能收集到的资料整体之间有何种关联? 这是一本社会科学的用户指南,既适用于本科生,也适用于研究生。作者不是仅仅提供一些机械的规则与应用,而是与读者一起对于方法问题进行通透的思考。他承认研究者也是人,因此也会像研究对象一样受制于同样的认知局限与扭曲,进而提出克服和弥补上述局限的办法。马丁论证了自律的重要性,说明学术伦理上出问题必将导致研究本身出问题,反之亦然。本书是一本里程碑式的作品;在社会学研究的过程中,学生们会反复从中受到启迪。
Read
Nov. 2, 2020
JLM是我很喜欢的一位作者。这是TT系列的第一本中译,是在所有社会科学研究方法种比较偏「实践」的一本。不是数据分析的方法(那是TTS的主题),而是如何系统、有效地进行实证思考。JLM的特点有几个:分析很多当代的实证研究,各种类型的都有;语言很活泼——事实上是有点太活泼,梗多到让人眼花缭乱;思路条理清晰。这本书没有回答的是一些更抽象层面的问题(比如说A研究和B研究的关系是什么),这三本书里的JLM是很坚定的实证主义者。所以在这方面他帮不了你。有幸在高老师翻译的过程中交流过,他的译笔流畅,很传神地还原了原作者的写作风格。诸位读者不要错过。研究生和博士生的课上都能用。希望以后重版的时候能把原书边码加上~
研究方法 社会学
Rethinking Expertise
Douban
Collins, Harry / Evans, Robert publishing house: University of Chicago Press 2009 - 3
What does it mean to be an expert? In "Rethinking Expertise", Harry Collins and Robert Evans offer a radical new perspective on the role of expertise in the practice of science and the public evaluation of technology. Collins and Evans present a Periodic Table of Expertises based on the idea of tacit knowledge - knowledge that we have but cannot explain. They then look at how some expertises are used to judge others, how laypeople judge between experts, and how credentials are used to evaluate them. Throughout, Collins and Evans ask an important question: how can the public make use of science and technology before there is consensus in the scientific community? This book has wide implications for public policy and for those who seek to understand science and benefit from it.
Read
Nov. 14, 2020
直观感觉是Collins走的「分类法」的路数是没前途的——总有新的分类可以找到;而分类之间又缺乏明显边界,总是给事后合理化提供理由。但是他的思路还是很有启发,尤其是给知识加上了一个互动论的底色。好读,有意思,比较糙(就理论而言)例子非常非常有趣。
知识社会学 STS 教师教育 社会学
The Levittowners
Douban
Herbert J. Gans / Harvey Molotch publishing house: Columbia University Press 1982
Read
Nov. 15, 2020
二战后美国的系统实证调查研究的典范作品,整整两年搬到新泽西新兴的「郊区」观察郊区生活是怎样的:does mass produced housing lead to mass produced lives? 现在滥觞的suburbia在当年还是一项新事物,充满了朝气和兴奋。缺点当然也跟当年的许多研究一样,白描为主。
美国 社区研究 都市社会学 社会学
文凭社会
The Credential Society Douban Goodreads
★ 7.9 17 ratings
[美]兰德尔·柯林斯 translator: 刘冉 publishing house: 北京大学出版社 2018 - 6
本书通过追溯19世纪下半叶到20世纪70年代晚期一百多年来的美国教育发展历史,主要以医学、法律和工程学教育为例,剖析了文凭社会是如何形成的、对社会产生的正面和负面影响,展现了文凭异化的过程,解释了学校教育与社会分层的内在关系,进而完成了对当代资本主义教育制度的反思和批判,最后则提出了化解文凭主义弊端的办法,预测了文凭主义在未来社会中的处境。 作者针砭时弊,揭穿了关于教育的诸多神话,认为建立在教育基础之上的文凭社会是一种不合理的分层机制,建议废除文凭。在当下这个文凭社会的势力越来越强的时代,书中内容有助于我们更好地理解当前面临的诸多教育问题,积极思谋应对之策。
Read
Nov. 18, 2020
托中文版的福,复习了一下柯林斯的论点。原来没注意到他在第六章里提出的是一个「职业霸权」论点(具体案例,如医生和工程师,是否可信还需要更多时间核实原始数据;不过在70年代这确实是一种主流论述),这个论点再嫁接到文化分层上面。
教育社会学 社会学
Degrees of Control
Douban
David K. Brown publishing house: Teachers College, Columbia University 1949
Read
Nov. 23, 2020
很可惜这本书被引用的很少。继承并发扬了柯林斯的理论框架基础,在微观层面叙事上更近一层。相比「文化货币」,Brown的「理性化职业需求」更符合直觉。
高等教育 教育社会学 社会学 历史
Complex Adaptive Systems
Douban
John H. Miller / Scott E. Page publishing house: Princeton University Press 2007 - 3
This book provides the first clear, comprehensive, and accessible account of complex adaptive social systems, by two of the field's leading authorities. Such systems - whether political parties, stock markets, or ant colonies - present some of the most intriguing theoretical and practical challenges confronting the social sciences. Engagingly written, and balancing technical detail with intuitive explanations, "Complex Adaptive Systems" focuses on the key tools and ideas that have emerged in the field since the mid-1990s, as well as the techniques needed to investigate such systems. It provides a detailed introduction to concepts such as emergence, self-organized criticality, automata, networks, diversity, adaptation, and feedback. It also demonstrates how complex adaptive systems can be explored using methods ranging from mathematics to computational models of adaptive agents. John Miller and Scott Page show how to combine ideas from economics, political science, biology, physics, and computer science to illuminate topics in organization, adaptation, decentralization, and robustness. They also demonstrate how the usual extremes used in modeling can be fruitfully transcended.
Read
Dec. 6, 2020
写得还挺好的一本用形式化方法阐述computation as social theory的书。蛮有趣的。杂感:形式化的书很容易写出民科感来。不是说这本书不好,只是读到「八正道框架」(第七章)的时候还感觉挺诈唬的。有趣的是学科似乎从来不与这些学者对话,或者说我还没观察到两者是如何互动的。比方说怎么处理偶然性?怎么处理micro-macro linkage?怎么处理时间性?或者在计算框架内,怎么理解优化?怎么理解局部收敛和协调?路很宽广。
复杂系统 形式化方法 社会学 方法论
An Elusive Science
Douban
Ellen Condliffe Lagemann publishing house: University Of Chicago Press 2002 - 5
Since its beginnings at the start of the 20th century, educational scholarship has been a marginal field, criticized by public policy makers and relegated to the fringes of academe. An Elusive Science explains why, providing a critical history of the traditions, conflicts, and institutions that have shaped the study of education over the past century.
Read
Dec. 6, 2021
五星推荐。非常完整的历史叙事,既accessible又充满洞见。这么多年以后重新回首这段历史——在博士班的时候我从身边老师那听过其中许多内容,但当时都自以为是地觉得「美国的历史有什么意思?」——才发现学科发展有那么多相似性。TC、斯坦福和哈佛在20世纪早期的历史和今天有非常多的相似之处。教育作为一个「有利可图」但低人一等的领域,与社会科学的其他学科保持着一种奇怪的动态。这一态势不单单在心理学,同样在教育管理,课程研究领域一再重复。当然,Lagemann的视角是教育领域内部,所以她忽视的是学科生态之间的关系,或者说,是过度决定导致生态没法出现;同样,二元论(杜威和桑代克、学校调查和心理测量、教育史和历史学者)也遮盖了学科知识发展的其他路径,一个最典型的例子当然是杜威的实用主义后代们。
职业社会学 社会学 高等教育 历史 教育社会学
Gifted Tongues
Douban
Fine, Gary Alan publishing house: Princeton University Press 2001 - 5
Learning to argue and persuade in a highly competitive environment is only one aspect of life on a high-school debate team. Teenage debaters also participate in a distinct cultural world--complete with its own jargon and status system--in which they must negotiate complicated relationships with teammates, competitors, coaches, and parents as well as classmates outside the debating circuit. In Gifted Tongues, Gary Alan Fine offers a rich description of this world as a testing ground for both intellectual and emotional development, while seeking to understand adolescents as social actors. Considering the benefits and drawbacks of the debating experience, he also recommends ways of reshaping programs so that more high schools can use them to boost academic performance and foster specific skills in citizenship. Fine analyzes the training of debaters in rapid-fire speech, rules of logical argumentation, and the strategic use of evidence, and how this training instills the core values of such American institutions as law and politics. Debates, however, sometimes veer quickly from fine displays of logic to acts of immaturity--a reflection of the tensions experienced by young people learning to think as adults. Fine contributes to our understanding of teenage years by encouraging us not to view them as a distinct stage of development but rather a time in which young people draw from a toolkit of both childlike and adult behaviors. A well-designed debate program, he concludes, nurtures the intellect while providing a setting in which teens learn to make better behavioral choices, ones that will shape relationships in their personal, professional, and civic lives.
Read
Jan. 12, 2021
辩论(更确切的说,argumentation)和美国文化的关系写的很好(p39-41),它既不是创造真理,也不简单是一种游戏。在规则之下生成了一种局部的「证据」,供参赛者们不断练习。可惜的是没看到辩手们和规则的互动,写的比较平铺直叙。最后,看到「文化作为一种工具箱」,我乐了。
教育社会学 青少年 教育 社会学
Becoming Adult
Douban
Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi / Barbara Schneider publishing house: Basic Books 2001 - 4
How do young people envision their occupational futures? What do teenagers feel about their schooling and after-school work, and how do these experiences affect their passage to adult work? These are the questions that psychologist Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi and sociologist Barbara Schneider posed in their five-year study of adolescents. The results provide an unprecedented window on society's future through which we can glimpse how today's youth are preparing themselves for the lives they will lead in the decades to come.
Read
Dec. 30, 2020
毕业时候从老师办公室拿的(她是作者之一),一直没看。作为90年代大规模社会调查的一部分,非常normal science。甚至连理论框架也没有——不管读者是否相信,基金会对于这类好读的作品愿意投钱。从某些方面来看,这是很有潜力的作品:通过把主观经验客观化,能开拓很多新的研究可能性,ESM方法显然拥有这种可能,但是限制其解释力的恰恰是对于个体经验狭义的操作化。结构性因素如何影响年轻人是通过每天8次记录时间用途可以回答的吗?微观的或者偶然的因素如何推动大的决策,这是普遍状态还是某种特例?这些问题都被扫到一边去了,最后就变成「另一项青少年研究」罢了。
青年研究 社会学
Situated Learning
Douban Goodreads
Jean Lave / Etienne Wenger publishing house: 劍橋大學出版社 1991 - 9
In this important theoretical treatist, Jean Lave, anthropologist, and Etienne Wenger, computer scientist, push forward the notion of situated learning - that learning is fundamentally a social process. The authors maintain that learning viewed as situated activity has as its central defining characteristic a process they call legitimate peripheral participation (LPP). Learners participate in communities of practitioners, moving toward full participation in the sociocultural practices of a community. LPP provides a way to speak about crucial relations between newcomers and old-timers and about their activities, identities, artefacts, knowledge and practice. The communities discussed in the book are midwives, tailors, quartermasters, butchers, and recovering alcoholics, however, the process by which participants in those communities learn can be generalised to other social groups.
Read
Jan. 10, 2021
LPP的概念非常吸引人,难怪人人都要引用。我觉得有意思的地方还在于提供了一个比较社会结构的视角来理解学习。写的短小精悍。要说不满的话,就是对于实践共同体的结构,知识和技能的定义都很浅显。毕竟要用屠夫剁肉(还不是庖丁那种)和裁缝做衣服来类比学术知识好像有那么点别扭。可换个角度,作为个人如何被实践共同体接纳,这个角度来看,也未尝不可。这本书催生了一大批研究,接下来好好看一下。
教育社会学 社会学 学习理论