美国
W. E. B. Du Bois's Data Portraits: Visualizing Black America
Douban Goodreads
The colorful charts, graphs, and maps presented at the 1900 Paris Exposition by famed sociologist and black rights activist W. E. B. Du Bois offered a view into the lives of black Americans, conveying a literal and figurative representation of "the color line." From advances in education to the lingering effects of slavery, these prophetic infographics-beautiful in design and powerful in content- make visible a wide spectrum of black experience. W. E. B. Du Bois's Data Portraits collects the complete set of graphics in full color for the first time, making their insights and innovations available to a contemporary imagination. As Maria Popova wrote, these data portraits shaped how "Du Bois himself thought about sociology, informing the ideas with which he set the world ablaze three years later in The Souls of Black Folk."
Read
June 19, 2020
1900年的作品,和现代的大数据可视化别无二致——不单单是设计,还有配色,与地图的搭配等等。Du Bois 比我想的还要多才多艺。当时能够想到这般利用和呈现社会统计数据,这才华让人惊叹。
黑人 美国 社会学 可视化
This Is How You Lose the Time War
This Is How You Lose the Time War Douban Goodreads Sukkertoppen
★ 7.2 26 ratings
Amal El-Mohtar / Max Gladstone publishing house: Gallery / Saga Press 2019 - 7
Two time-traveling agents from warring futures, working their way through the past, begin to exchange letters—and fall in love in this thrilling and romantic book from award-winning authors Amal-El Mohtar and Max Gladstone. Among the ashes of a dying world, an agent of the Commandant finds a letter. It reads: Burn before reading. Thus begins an unlikely correspondence between two rival agents hellbent on securing the best possible future for their warring factions. Now, what began as a taunt, a battlefield boast, grows into something more. Something epic. Something romantic. Something that could change the past and the future. Except the discovery of their bond would mean death for each of them. There’s still a war going on, after all. And someone has to win that war. That’s how war works. Right? Cowritten by two beloved and award-winning sci-fi writers, This Is How You Lose the Time War is an epic love story spanning time and space.
Read
Aug. 7, 2020
现在雨果奖(中长篇)加持了。非常非常特别。采取的形式是「写信」:两位敌对阵营的时间特工在出任务时因某种巧合而相遇相知,开始了通信。整本书最妙的部分就是二人穿梭在人类社会的各个时空出任务,然后在奇妙/壮阔的场景下给对方留下笔迹(比如亚特兰蒂斯毁灭之前、成吉思汗的大帐里、十九世纪的伦敦帝国酒店)等等。主角分属两个「时间终点」阵营:一个是技术乌托邦,另一个类似于蜂巢意识的类神体。所以剧情由一开始两人完全不同的世界观冲撞到后期开始逐渐了解对方所展示出的种种柔情——读的人心都融化了,非常的浪漫。这本书文字洗炼,很「意识流」:在100多页里塞下了10多种场景,可见用字多么节省,但同样,可能不对硬核读者的胃口。连带读者未必买账的是幻想绝对多于科学。内核的「理解」和「爱」的观念又没太多新花样。俏皮文艺清新。
中篇 美国 雨果奖 时间旅行 科幻
To Dwell among Friends
Douban
Claude S. Fischer publishing house: University Of Chicago Press 1982 - 4
Read
Aug. 7, 2020
仔细扎实不浮夸,关于社区的个人体验,也是关于社会网络——在形式化方法开始大行其道之前。Problemtizing the obvious: 与小镇相比城市生活并没有改变个人关系,而是带来了不同的形式。封面可能是我读过社会学书里最可爱的了吧。
美国 社区研究 都市社会学 社会学
沙丘
Dune Douban Goodreads Eggplant.place
★ 7.5 161 ratings
[美] 弗兰克·赫伯特 translator: 潘振华 publishing house: 江苏凤凰文艺出版社 2017 - 2
人类每次正视自己的渺小,都是自身的一次巨大进步。 —————————— 哥白尼提出了“日心说”,我们才知道这个世界并不是宇宙的中心。 哈勃用望远镜揭开了河外星系的神秘面纱,我们才知道宇宙中还有千亿个银河系。 “自由号”发现了黑洞的存在,我们才知道也许宇宙之外还有宇宙,我 们只是永恒中一颗微小的沙粒。 - 一切会思考的机器都被摧毁后,宇宙的焦点重回人类之间的争夺。行星厄拉科斯——人类梦寐以求、竞相抢夺的“香料”的唯一产地,在这里上演着权术与背叛、恐惧与仇恨、希望与梦想的太空歌剧。人们常常用另一个名字称呼这颗干旱的星球——沙丘。 家破人亡、颠沛流离的少年保罗在这里抗争着他的宿命。在命运面前,他是如此的渺小,却又如此的强大…… —————————— ◆《沙丘》是伟大的科幻作家弗兰克•赫伯特的传奇代表作。 - ◆每个“一生必读”的书单上都有《沙丘》 - ◆美国亚马逊“一生必读的100本书” - ◆BBC“英国最受欢迎的100本书” - ◆美国国家公共电台“科幻•奇幻小说TOP100” - ◆摘得《轨迹》杂志“20世纪最佳科幻小说”桂冠 - ◆首部同时获得雨果奖与星云奖的作品,科幻小说史上的必读经典。 - ◆人类每次正视自己的渺小,都是自身的一次巨大进步。 - ◆《沙丘》在科幻文学中的地位就如同《魔戒》在奇幻文学中的地位。 - ◆风靡全球半个多世纪,全球销量已突破1200万册。 - ◆《沙丘》被改编成红遍全球的即时战略游戏的鼻祖《沙丘魔堡》,由此衍生出的《红色警戒》《星际争霸》几乎成为每台电脑上的必装品。 - ◆催生了《星球大战》《阿凡达》等经典科幻电影。 —————————— 媒体及名人推荐 《沙丘》在科幻文学中的地位就如同《魔戒》在奇幻文学中的地位。 ——《图书馆杂志》 - 科幻小说史上的里程碑。 ——《芝加哥论坛报》 - 这部作品所描绘的外星星球比其他科幻作家所描绘的更完整、更细腻,完美地平衡了技术描写和心理描写。 ——《华盛顿邮报》 - 随着气候变化、中东局势、能源危机层出不穷,《沙丘》比50年前更具现实意义。如果你还没看过,的确该找来读读。 ——《纽约时报》 - 赫伯特对于这个星球的创造,包含了复杂的情节发展,以及对生态、宗教、政治和哲学,是科幻史上一个伟大而又影响深远的成就——《路易斯维尔时报》 - 极强的感染力,情节令人信服,绝对天才的创意。——《星船伞兵》作者罗伯特•A•海因莱因 - 《沙丘》在故事的生动复杂方面,《沙丘》同金庸的小说有的一比。《沙丘》又不仅仅是一部科幻小说,这里面有政治,经济,军事,宗教,生态学,未来学等等,更把人性、人的本质、人的目的放在一个宇宙的尺度上进行终极思考,这个规模恐怕又是金庸所不及的了。 ——复旦大学中文系教授严锋 - 独一无二。只有《指环王》可以与之媲美。 ——英国著名科幻作家阿瑟•C•克拉克 - 如果你只读过这部杰作的外延或改编作品,你都不算真的了解《沙丘》是怎么回事。这是一次“必须通过阅读才能完全领略的全沉浸式的体验”。——《合成人》作者帕特•卡蒂根 - 现代科幻史上的标杆之一,想象力创造上的丰碑。 ——美国科幻作家P•斯凯勒•米勒 - 在16岁那年,我第一次被《沙丘》打动,它成了我心目中的神作。八年来,很少有书能撼动它在我心中的地位,包括《权力的游戏》、《基地》、《安德的游戏》和《指环王》。于是,我又重读了一遍《沙丘》,发现16岁那年的感动历久弥新。真的有那么棒吗?当然了! ——读者评论 - 我经常默念书中的“恐惧是思维杀手”这句话。恐惧——通常是对失败的恐惧——是我们思维清晰、专注的最大障碍。默念这句话并不能消除恐惧,而是让我意识到恐惧并直视它。 ——读者评论
The Levittowners
Douban
Herbert J. Gans / Harvey Molotch publishing house: Columbia University Press 1982
Read
Nov. 15, 2020
二战后美国的系统实证调查研究的典范作品,整整两年搬到新泽西新兴的「郊区」观察郊区生活是怎样的:does mass produced housing lead to mass produced lives? 现在滥觞的suburbia在当年还是一项新事物,充满了朝气和兴奋。缺点当然也跟当年的许多研究一样,白描为主。
美国 社区研究 都市社会学 社会学
An Elusive Science
Douban
Ellen Condliffe Lagemann publishing house: University Of Chicago Press 2002 - 5
Since its beginnings at the start of the 20th century, educational scholarship has been a marginal field, criticized by public policy makers and relegated to the fringes of academe. An Elusive Science explains why, providing a critical history of the traditions, conflicts, and institutions that have shaped the study of education over the past century.
Read
Dec. 6, 2021
五星推荐。非常完整的历史叙事,既accessible又充满洞见。这么多年以后重新回首这段历史——在博士班的时候我从身边老师那听过其中许多内容,但当时都自以为是地觉得「美国的历史有什么意思?」——才发现学科发展有那么多相似性。TC、斯坦福和哈佛在20世纪早期的历史和今天有非常多的相似之处。教育作为一个「有利可图」但低人一等的领域,与社会科学的其他学科保持着一种奇怪的动态。这一态势不单单在心理学,同样在教育管理,课程研究领域一再重复。当然,Lagemann的视角是教育领域内部,所以她忽视的是学科生态之间的关系,或者说,是过度决定导致生态没法出现;同样,二元论(杜威和桑代克、学校调查和心理测量、教育史和历史学者)也遮盖了学科知识发展的其他路径,一个最典型的例子当然是杜威的实用主义后代们。
职业社会学 社会学 高等教育 历史 教育社会学
Kingdom of Children
Douban
Mitchell L. Stevens publishing house: Princeton University Press 2001
More than one million American children are schooled by their parents. As their ranks grow, home schoolers are making headlines by winning national spelling bees and excelling at elite universities. The few studies conducted suggest that homeschooled children are academically successful and remarkably well socialized. Yet we still know little about this alternative to one of society’s most fundamental institutions. Beyond a vague notion of children reading around the kitchen table, we don’t know what home schooling looks like from the inside. Sociologist Mitchell Stevens goes behind the scenes of the homeschool movement and into the homes and meetings of home schoolers. What he finds are two very different kinds of home education—one rooted in the liberal alternative school movement of the 1960s and 1970s and one stemming from the Christian day school movement of the same era. Stevens explains how this dual history shapes the meaning and practice of home schooling today. In the process, he introduces us to an unlikely mix of parents (including fundamentalist Protestants, pagans, naturalists, and educational radicals) and notes the core values on which they agree: the sanctity of childhood and the primacy of family in the face of a highly competitive, bureaucratized society. Kingdom of Children aptly places home schoolers within longer traditions of American social activism. It reveals that home schooling is not a random collection of individuals but an elaborate social movement with its own celebrities, networks, and characteristic lifeways. Stevens shows how home schoolers have built their philosophical and religious convictions into the practical structure of the cause, and documents the political consequences of their success at doing so. Ultimately, the history of home schooling serves as a parable about the organizational strategies of the progressive left and the religious right since the 1960s.Kingdom of Children shows what happens when progressive ideals meet conventional politics, demonstrates the extraordinary political capacity of conservative Protestantism, and explains the subtle ways in which cultural sensibility shapes social movement outcomes more generally.
Read
Jan. 19, 2021
作者的博士论文,写的是1990年代HS运动。他认为HS是一场社会运动,有一个文化结构(60年代以降的expanded self)配合美国独特的教育市场(分散)、偏向于个体自由的法律环境,还有结合一批关注个体的教育意识形态,当然,还有契合宗教右翼的主张。我觉得不好的地方是正好夹在民族志和历史叙事的中间。他的个体材料跟整体论点之间联系很薄弱。最后,想想中国今天的育儿市场:蒙台梭利、Emilia Reggio、华德福——每一个都能在HS运动里找到他们的身影。想来这个理念能引起很大的共鸣。
社会运动 教育社会学 美国 社会学
Contentious Curricula
Douban
Amy J. Binder publishing house: Princeton University Press 2004 - 5
This book compares two challenges made to American public school curricula in the 1980s and 1990s. It identifies striking similarities between proponents of Afrocentrism and creationism, accounts for their differential outcomes, and draws important conclusions for the study of culture, organizations, and social movements. Amy Binder gives a brief history of both movements and then describes how their challenges played out in seven school districts. Despite their very different constituencies - inner-city African American cultural essentialists and predominately white suburban Christian conservatives - Afrocentrists and creationists had much in common. Both made similar arguments about oppression and their children's well-being, both faced skepticism from educators about their factual claims, and both mounted their challenges through bureaucratic channels. In each case, challenged school systems were ultimately able to minimize or reject challengers' demands, but the process varied by case and type of challenge. Binder finds that Afrocentrists were more successful in advancing their cause than were creationists because they appeared to offer a solution to the real problem of urban school failure, met with more administrative sympathy toward their complaints of historic exclusion, sought to alter lower-prestige curricula (history, not science), and faced opponents who lacked a legal remedy comparable to the rule of church-state separation invoked by creationism's opponents. Binder's analysis yields several lessons for social movements research, suggesting that researchers need to pay greater attention to how movements seek to influence bureaucratic decision making, often from within. It also demonstrates the benefits of examining discursive, structural, and institutional factors in concert.
Read
Feb. 26, 2021
很有理论自觉,意识到要研究非洲中心主义或者创世论不单单是文化社会学的问题,也摄取了社会运动和组织理论的养分。要把三条线索有机结合在一起不容易(这一点上本研究还有不足),但整体感觉很清晰,提出很多靠谱的研究思路。7个比较例子也很扎实。值得推荐。
文化社会学 教育 社会运动 社会学 教育社会学
From Higher Aims to Hired Hands
Douban
Rakesh Khurana publishing house: Princeton University Press 2007 - 9
Is management a profession? Should it be? Can it be? This major work of social and intellectual history reveals how such questions have driven business education and shaped American management and society for more than a century. The book is also a call for reform. Rakesh Khurana shows that university-based business schools were founded to train a professional class of managers in the mold of doctors and lawyers but have effectively retreated from that goal, leaving a gaping moral hole at the center of business education and perhaps in management itself.</p> Khurana begins in the late nineteenth century, when members of an emerging managerial elite, seeking social status to match the wealth and power they had accrued, began working with major universities to establish graduate business education programs paralleling those for medicine and law. Constituting business as a profession, however, required codifying the knowledge relevant for practitioners and developing enforceable standards of conduct. Khurana, drawing on a rich set of archival material from business schools, foundations, and academic associations, traces how business educators confronted these challenges with varying strategies during the Progressive era and the Depression, the postwar boom years, and recent decades of freewheeling capitalism.</p> Today, Khurana argues, business schools have largely capitulated in the battle for professionalism and have become merely purveyors of a product, the MBA, with students treated as consumers. Professional and moral ideals that once animated and inspired business schools have been conquered by a perspective that managers are merely agents of shareholders, beholden only to the cause of share profits. According to Khurana, we should not thus be surprised at the rise of corporate malfeasance. The time has come, he concludes, to rejuvenate intellectually and morally the training of our future business leaders.</p>
Read
May 8, 2021
终于找时间读完了。非常棒的作品,整体思路清晰,写得也漂亮。把商学院的历史分成三段,每段都很有特点(寻找合法性、确立规范、市场化+学科化之后陷入的危机)。理论部分可能是我不太满意的,比方说商学院和经济系的互动是怎么样的?多学科交融之后又是如何处理学科自己的管辖权呢?更重要的是,外生和内生变量有点混为一团,比如80年代兼并狂潮(以及没有提到的,全球化)如何冲击了商业管理的概念(第七章提供了简单叙事)。但总体而言写得好。
历史社会学 职业史 美国 历史
The Future of the Army Profession
Douban
Matthews, Lloyd J. (EDT) publishing house: McGraw-Hill College 2005 - 4
Read
May 10, 2021
少有的社会学家理论被应用在当代职业研究中:这本书的由来是美国军校的教授们试图回答「美国军队究竟变成了现代化职业还是单纯的科层组织?」——答案是职业化项目完成之后军队就开始向后者变化了。很有意思的是,这是本书的第二版,恰逢阿富汗战争开打,作者们说军队的专家知识得益于战争(但在其它方面受到战争的负面影响,比方道德性)。还有,因为不是学术书籍,写作风格很新鲜,起码在那些军人作者的章节里,字里行间都有一股很利索的感觉(看看表9-1,社会学家谁会费心写这么多?)
军事社会学 职业社会学 美国
世界的词语是森林
The Word for World Is Forest Douban
★ 8.6 64 ratings
[美国] 厄休拉·勒古恩 translator: 于国君 publishing house: 北京联合出版公司 2017 - 11
在遥远的星球上,住着一群绿毛、大眼睛的原住民。 他们喜爱做清明梦,依靠森林,过着与世无争的生活。 一天,一群贪婪的殖民者来到这里,破坏了原有的一切。 绝望的原住民,开始报复。 然而,对入侵者的每一次报复,也是对自己人性的一次摧残。 他们一步一步,离昔日的自我越来越远。 杀戮一旦开始,没有人能再回到原点。 宇宙深处有一面镜子,可以看见真正的自己。
Read
July 1, 2021
今天在带孩子和地铁上读完了这个中篇。第六、七章的情感冲击尤其强烈,非常了不起的作品,关于梦/时间、现实、暴力与和解。不要只把这本书当成是「反战」作品。作者有更深刻的关于异种族之间交流的想法:But to the Athsheans soil, ground, earth was not that to which the dead return and by which the living live: the substance of their world was not earth, but forest. Terran man was clay, red dust. Athshean man was branch and root. 其中关于「神」的论述尤其精彩。
科幻 雨果奖 美国
Measuring Up
Douban
Koretz, Daniel publishing house: Harvard University Press 2009 - 9
How do you judge the quality of a school, a district, a teacher, a student? By the test scores, of course. Yet for all the talk, what educational tests can and can't tell you, and how scores can be misunderstood and misused, remains a mystery to most. The complexities of testing are routinely ignored, either because they are unrecognized, or because they may be - well, complicated. Inspired by a popular Harvard course for students without an extensive mathematics background, "Measuring Up" demystifies educational testing - from MCAS to SAT to WAIS, with all the alphabet soup in between. Bringing statistical terms down to earth, Daniel Koretz takes readers through the most fundamental issues that arise in educational testing and shows how they apply to some of the most controversial issues in education today, from high-stakes testing to special education. He walks readers through everyday examples to show what tests do well, what their limits are, how easily tests and scores can be oversold or misunderstood, and how they can be used sensibly to help discover how much kids have learned.
Read
July 27, 2021
很多年前稀里糊涂地读过,没留下印象。今天重新读了一遍,还是很不错的关于考试(心理测量)的入门读物。没有涉及到特别多技术方面或者观念方面的讨论,很适合第一次接触考试理论,分析考分的读者。语言非常大众化。
心理计量 教育 美国
Varieties of Liberalization and the New Politics of Social Solidarity
Douban
Kathleen Thelen publishing house: 劍橋大學出版社 2014 - 6
This book examines contemporary changes in labor market institutions in the United States, Germany, Denmark, Sweden, and the Netherlands, focusing on developments in three arenas - industrial relations, vocational education and training, and labor market policy. While confirming a broad, shared liberalizing trend, it finds that there are in fact distinct varieties of liberalization associated with very different distributive outcomes. Most scholarship equates liberal capitalism with inequality and coordinated capitalism with higher levels of social solidarity. However, this study explains why the institutions of coordinated capitalism and egalitarian capitalism coincided and complemented one another in the "Golden Era" of postwar development in the 1950s and 1960s, and why they no longer do so. Contrary to the conventional wisdom, this study reveals that the successful defense of the institutions traditionally associated with coordinated capitalism has often been a recipe for increased inequality due to declining coverage and dualization. Conversely, it argues that some forms of labor market liberalization are perfectly compatible with continued high levels of social solidarity and indeed may be necessary to sustain it.
Law School
Douban
Stevens, Robert 1987 - 2
In this first general history of legal education, Stevens traces the development of law schools, the legal profession, and legal thought, relating their evolution to intellectual, political, and social trends. He describes how the establishment gained power over education after 1920 and how, in the past two decades, both students and the practicing profession have questioned this authority. He also examines the implications of the "legal revolution" and new opportunities for women and minorities.
Read
Sept. 16, 2021
史料不错。浅显易懂。中译也很过硬。给我一个启发:塑造职业教育更多的是不是来自职业本身的特性(比方上庭、男性主导、以及垄断)。
职业社会学 美国
Failing Law Schools
Douban
Brian Z. Tamanaha publishing house: University Of Chicago Press 2012 - 6
On the surface, law schools today are thriving. Enrollments are on the rise, and their resources are often the envy of every other university department. Yet behind the flourishing facade, law schools are failing abjectly. Recent front-page stories have detailed widespread dubious practices, misleading placement reports, and the fundamental failure to prepare graduates to enter the profession. Addressing all these problems and more in a ringing critique is renowned legal scholar Brian Z. Tamanaha. Piece by piece, Tamanaha lays out the how and why of the crisis and the likely consequences if the current trend continues. At the heart of the problem, he argues, are the economic demands and competitive pressures on law schools - driven by competition over U.S. News and World Report ranking. When paired with a lack of regulatory oversight, the work environment of professors, the limited information available to prospective students, and loan-based tuition financing, the result is a system that is fundamentally unsustainable. With "Failing Law Schools", Tamanaha has provided the perfect resource for assessing what's wrong with law schools and figuring out how to fix them.
Read
Sept. 20, 2021
法学院内幕。我觉得和医学院很类似,还有其他专业学院也能类比。就是这个以纯以市场为导向(排名、校友捐款、LSAT成绩,录取率)的模式有利于一小部分精英学校,代价由其余学校和学生承担:学费高昂、效率低下、找不到工作,等等。其中有一小节吐槽法学研究无助于法律实践,也满有意思的。
职业社会学 法学 美国
Turning the Soul
Douban
Haroutunian-Gordon, Sophie 1991 - 4
Is our nation's educational system faltering in part because it strives to teach students predetermined "right" answers to questions? In "Turning the Soul," Sophie Haroutunian-Gordon offers and alternative to methods advocated by conventional educational practice. By guiding the reader back and forth between two high school classes discussing Shakespeare's "Romeo and Juliet," she gracefully introduces the alternative approach to education: interpretive discussion. One class, located in a private, racially integrated urban school, has had many conversations about the meaning of books. The second group, less advantaged students in a largely black urban school, has not. The reader watches as students in each group begin to draw upon experiences in their personal lives to speculate about events in the play. The students assist one another with the interpretation of complex passages, pose queries that help sustain the conversation, and struggle to "get Shakespeare right." Though the teachers suffer moments of intense frustration, they are rewarded by seeing their students learn to engage in meaningful exchange. Because "Turning the Soul" draws on actual classroom conversations, it presents the range of difficulties that one encounters in interpretive discussion. The book describes the assumptions about learning that the use of such discussion in the classroom presupposes, and it offers a theoretical perspective from which to view the changes in both students and teachers.
Read
Dec. 5, 2021
很好的课堂民族志。两间学校,同一门课程(阅读《罗密欧与茱丽叶》),围绕在「讨论如何建构、发展」这个中心议题上。框架上很传统,杜威的「making forward and backward connection」。阐释地很细,比当代一众lesson study要好太多。
教育社会学 美国 民族志
Knowledge in the Time of Cholera
Douban
Whooley, Owen publishing house: University of Chicago Press 2013 - 4
Vomiting. Diarrhea. Dehydration. Death. Confusion. In 1832, the arrival of cholera in the United States created widespread panic throughout the country. For the rest of the century, epidemics swept through American cities and towns, killing thousands. Physicians of all stripes offered conflicting answers to the cholera puzzle, ineffectively responding with opiates, bleeding, quarantines, and all manner of remedies, before the identity of the dreaded infection was consolidated under the germ theory of disease some sixty years later. These cholera outbreaks raised fundamental questions about medical knowledge and its legitimacy, giving fuel to alternative medical sects that used the confusion of the epidemic to challenge both medical orthodoxy and the authority of the still-new American Medical Association. In "Knowledge in the Time of Cholera", Owen Whooley tells us the story of those dark days, centering his narrative on rivalries between medical and homeopathic practitioners and bringing to life the battle to control public understanding of disease, professional power, and democratic governance in nineteenth-century America.
Read
Dec. 8, 2021
把职业和知识社会学结合在一起的作品。一方面是职业的生态理论,另一方面是认识论对于不同医疗派别之间turf war(医治霍乱大流行)的影响。从大体结论上来说没有特别出彩的地方:对抗疗法派最终成为了AMA,并且将「霍乱微生物说」纳入自己的话语/知识系统里,从而完成了epistemic closure。但turf war有很多不同打法,认识论争议甚至可能算不上必要条件(pp.230)。突出知识的一面确实有新意,但对于大图景,以及其他职业化过程的作用,我还是心存疑虑。
职业社会学 社会学 STS 医疗 美国
Ghosts in the Schoolyard
Douban
Eve Ewing publishing house: University of Chicago Press 2018
Read
Dec. 9, 2021
两星半。像是长篇幅的op-ed。作者的写作能力很强(她出版了各种类型的书),也是一个非常engaging的人,但对于期望有历史感或者理论导向的读者来说比较失望。这个议题上已经积累了大量的经验和论证,我不觉得本书在这方面提出任何新意,当然她饱含情感(作者自己教书的一家学校就是被关闭的之一,里面的人和事都写得很好),但如果说「保存我们的文化传统」是一声呼喊,同样的论点反过来用不也一样吗?
教育社会学 社会学 美国